I had pretty much expected the Twins would trade a bat and that Arcia would be called up. As we know this did not happen but the question remains on what to do with Arcia. My initial instinct was to say call him up yesterday but thinking about it some more does anyone think there is some value in having him avoid the death march of the dog days of August and instead keep him on a winning team that is driving for the playoffs in Rochester? He obviously misses the major league reps but he does gain some other aspects of development that could pay dividends in a couple of years.
Cain would have been nice. This is a semantics debate. Liriano was a lottery ticket in that context but is still a better prospect than anything the Twins would have gotten for Morneau at this time.
No. You can't get an established major league reliever for Morneau right now. You have a very warped sense of what "lottery ticket" means in this context. None would be close to the caliber of Liriano at the time of that trade.
I know you aren't one to hold back hyperbole in your negativity, but I don't think anyone said Gardy was doing a "great" job. He's probably doing more or less what any manager would do with this collection of talent.
Willingham's value was never that high no matter what people continue to believe. Certainly not higher than Revere or Span returns. What was your source? And even if this "source" is correct what does that return even mean? Perhaps that was the bigger sticking point than money. Why eat money and give Morneau away for nothing? They can do that in August just as easily.
I agree with this. It would take a very unique situation for this to happen. It bothers me a little that national guys like Law mention this so casually even with so few examples to draw from.
I was thinking this too. I think a main reason is what they have squeezed out of this bullpen. Despite many criticisms of hid bullpen management I also found it to be a strength. Improved defense is a big factor too.
The other option is to pass him through waivers in early August (assuming no one claims the contract) and hope he rebounds enough to get a little more value sometime later in the month.
I would add too that the positions that are killing the Twins offensively are the corners and those are by far the easiest to shore up on a roster. It's just not nearly the concern to me that starting pitching is.
Read the rumors - they are big names that lead to clicks but probably won't be moved (ahem, Cliff Lee). National writers don't waste their time on the bit guys the Twins might trade. No one gets excited for Duensing or Burton.
This is most likely true in the long term but is far from a certainty in the next couple of seasons both because Dozier could improve and Rosario could take some time. This will play out appropriately.