I get that long terms deals have a tendency to flame out, yes. The Pujols and Cabrera deals though are so different from the situation with Correa.
Pujols and Miggy both signed those deals going into the season having turned 32. Both play the easiest position to replace, offensively and defensively in 1st, so not much value there as they age. I look at those contracts on what to avoid in a player.
Correa, who's 27, is the best defensive shortstop in baseball and has a career wRC+ of about 130. That's not even considering that fact that he might actually somehow reach a higher ceiling at the plate.
If he needs to move over to 3rd as his range diminishes in 5-6 years, fine. He's got plenty enough arm. You have a gold glove 3rd baseman.
I understand your point with Larnach and Pena, they look great, but they've also played MLB for about 5 minutes.