On top of all that, he's arguably the greatest fielding lefty in modern history. Greg Maddux once said that he envied Buehrle's defensive skills. So, is Buehrle a HOFer? 214 wins just short of 3300 innings after tomorrow 1870 strikeouts 116 career ERA+ 5 All-Star games, 4 Gold Gloves, one Cy Young top-5 finish 60 bWAR career He is short on black ink, gray ink, and JAWS, but I wonder if there will be a movement to get him in. Thing is that the guy is only 36. He's still pitching solid and could hang around for another 3-5 years to attempt to get 250+ wins.