I have looked closely at Gardy's decisions. His in game decisions are pretty conservative. His decisions on when to pull the starter are based on the pitch-count and age of the pitcher. He also is pretty traditional about lefty/righty substitutions He uses all his players on a weekly basis to keep them sharp. His pinch hitters are about what you would expect. He gives players a rest when they are hurt and/or tired. There is no way to judge the affect he has on his players, except that they don't quit. Look at how many games they fell behind, but kept battling back. We hear him giving players a pat on the back. We don't often hear about when he kicks a players butt. What happens in the clubhouse, stays in the clubhouse. You don't see a lot of back-biting and finger-pointing from his players. Players may not want to come to Minnesota, but once they are here, they seem to want to stay. Is that because Gardy is a good manager to play for? Until the players start complaining about Gardy, I see no upside in firing him.