Brooks Lee was drafted by the Twins in 2022 as the eighth pick in the first round of the MLB draft. Most observers thought the Twins did well to get a polished college hitter with their pick. He was thought to be a very good hitter who was a polished defender. Add in that Lee is a switch hitter capable of playing shortstop and it appeared that the Twins hit a home run with their pick.
Lee advanced quickly despite injuries and made his debut last year at age 23. After a good first week in the majors, Brooks struggled with the rest of the team in the last quarter of the season, finishing with a .221 average and .585 OPS. Twins watchers suggested that his back injury and first season that ran past Labor Day may have sapped his strength.
Maybe so, but the numbers didn't show a picture of an elite hitter or fielder. Most of the metrics show an average-ish hitter with poor leg speed and not much athleticism. 2025 opened with Lee on the IL again to start the season. He's been on the team since he's been activated and he's started almost every day, playing double digit games at second, short and third. In conjunction with Willi Castro, Lee gives the team great versatility and both guys are also switch hitters. Lee's batting average and OPS are improved from last year, but not dramatically so. His OPS+ is a very pedestrian 76, he's hit four homers and has 18 RBI. However, his manager has used him frequently in the middle of the lineup, hitting third eight times and fourth nine times in the 39 games he has started. His usage seems to indicate faith that he will produce good numbers.
Given the struggles of three other infielders who have been on the team--Miranda, Julien and Royce Lewis--it seems that Lee will continue to be in the lineup almost every day for the foreseeable future. What I am wondering is what his future will be in the next few years. Will he assume a position and be a regular? Will he stay on the team as a three-position infielder getting plenty of at-bats or will others pass him by where he may or may not play significant time for the Twins.
My thoughts are that Lee is better than his numbers, but there's no evidence yet that he is any more than an average player. He is quite polished and makes up for much of his lack of speed and arm strength on defense, enough so that he is a capable defender, particularly at third base. Still, he has to hit better than he's shown or he'll be a wasted first round pick. I can envision Lee assuming Willi Castro's role as a starter at multiple positions. Maybe he can become an everyday starter at second or third, but there isn't evidence that he will ever hit enough to claim a position for himself.