I agree a lot with this. I find scouting reports of prospects useful that try to peg a pitcher's role, "could be a #1," "slots somewhere as a #2/3" etc., but I think it's crazy to say "ceiling is a #5". There is no such thing! You don't see a guy hold the #5 spot in a rotation for three or four years - not even a full season, usually. Whereas, for position players, it makes perfect sense to say that Jake Cave or Ehire Adrianza's best role is as a backup. #5 is for prospects being given a first chance, and veterans given a last chance. Thin ice, always. It's not a job, it's an opportunity. If you're signing a guy for millions with #5 in mind, it can't be the best use for that money. Just can't. Hopefully a Shoemaker contract isn't for much.