I understand why we brought him in for a shot last year (toolsy upside) and I even understood why we handed him the 26th man job this season (Glimmer of upside, no options, Buxton insurance, low wattage role), but 2 things have happened now.
1. He's stunk
2. Kreidler is on the roster
Kreidler is just as good of Buxton insurance as Outman was AND he's an elite defensive infielder. As long as Kreidler is on the roster, Outman is completely extraneous. And extraneous in a role that's designed to be low usage is not a good place to be. I assume what it's coming down to is how long the Twins think Royce will be on the IL. If it's just for one more week, then I GUESS they can keep kicking the Outman can down the road, but I really think it's just time to move on.
I'm totally cool with calling Emma up if they can find him consistent AB at least 5 days a week. His problem has been health and right now he's healthy, so let's do it. As has been stated, this likely means less playing time for Caratini and Clemens, but I'm fine with that. Part of me wonders if they are looking out over a week for when they might be facing fewer LH starters. Obviously you can't project that with 100% accuracy, but you can get a pretty good idea. At the very least you could probably project when we might be facing the toughest lefties (have we already face all the best lefties in the league?), which is who you'd shield Emma against, if anyone.