Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    We Can Rebuild It: Creative Bullpen Fixes


    Nick Nelson

    The Twins bullpen situation has turned catastrophic, and there's nothing to be gained by wringing hands over how we got here.

    These are the facts: Minnesota is above .500 and very much in the mix as we enter June, but the Twins won't likely hang around unless they do something to address the relief corps. That "something" doesn't need to be drastic nor detrimental to the big picture.

    Image courtesy of Jesse Johnson, USA Today

    Twins Video

    The Twins aren't in any position to make an Andrew Miller-type splash, and would be ill-advised to dangle any of their better prospects – even a Chih-Wei Hu type – for relief help (insofar as any high-impact relievers are being made available this far from the deadline).

    In order to meaningfully improve their chances in the late innings, the front office might need to get creative. Sure, they can try someone like Alan Busenitz or Trevor Hildenberger, but you can't just count on green rookies with iffy scouting reports to come up and shut down the eighth inning. By the same token, newly promoted farmhands Alex Wimmers and Randy Rosario are more band aids than plugs.

    The following suggestions are aimed at creating a more dramatic short-term impact, without forfeiting anything of import.

    Move Phil Hughes to the Bullpen

    Hughes is currently on the disabled list but there have been indications he won't stay there too terribly long. When he returns, the Twins might be wise to bring him back in a relief role. There are multiple beneficial outcomes this route could achieve.

    His fastball has been humming in at the lowest velocity of his career, and getting pounded as a result. It's possible Hughes could add a few ticks in shorter stints. Of course, he's had tremendous success out of the bullpen before, serving as Mariano Rivera's top setup man when the Yankees won the World Series in 2009. Hughes' numbers that season: 86 IP, 3.03 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 96/28 K/BB.

    He isn't likely to regain that level of superior efficacy, especially not right away, but maybe Hughes will surprise us. He has the command and poise that so many other Twins relievers are lacking, so even a slight uptick in heat – and perhaps a reduced reliance on his lesser offerings – could make a big difference.

    Swap Tyler Duffey and Brandon Kintzler

    This isn't so much a denouncement of what either right-hander has done in his current role – they've been the bullpen's two best weapons – as it is an assertion they may be best suited for a reversal.

    Kintzler has done an admirable job in the ninth, but always struck me as a guy better equipped for the middle innings. His penchant for inducing ground balls on command would make him an excellent fireman, called upon in a tough spot with runners on base. He has also proven fairly durable, and could likely handle multiple innings on a frequent basis.

    Meanwhile, Duffey is much more of a prototypical closer, with his bat-missing stuff, and has experience in the role from his collegiate days at Rice University.

    Call up Fernando Romero

    Minnesota's legit relief prospects can't seem to get healthy. Nick Burdi is out for the season after undergoing Tommy John surgery. JT Chargois went on the disabled list in April with an elbow impingement and still hasn't returned. Tyler Jay missed the first seven weeks with a shoulder injury, came back a week ago, made two appearances and then landed back on the DL. I'm starting to lose hope that any of these guys will be available to the Twins at any point this year.

    That's a huge problem because they are THE minor-league arms that could actually bring game-changing shutdown ability to the table. If the Twins want to find that now, they may need to consider calling up Romero from Double-A. Twins Daily's No. 1 prospect has gotten on a roll in Chattanooga lately, firing 12 scoreless innings over his past two starts, and as someone who works in the mid-90s as a starter he could really dial it up in short stints.

    The additional benefit is that this might help manage the 22-year-old's workload; he's already more than halfway to last season's total of 90 innings. The downside is that it would essentially remove him as a potential rotation reinforcement, unless the coaching staff wanted to stretch him out after he arrives. (Wouldn't be the first time.)

    Mine for Spare Parts in Other Organizations

    While we've ruled out giving up a prospect of Wilson Ramos' or even Hu's caliber, the Twins might be able to inherit a project that some other organization is ready to give up on. Maybe there is a fifth/sixth starter out there that Derek Falvey and Thad Levine view as a particularly good candidate for a role switch. Or perhaps there is a Michael Tonkin or Ryan Pressly type, with big stuff and disappointing results, who they believe they can turn around with a specific fix. The cost of such an acquisition would be negligible.

    It would be a good opportunity for the new regime, especially Falvey with his reputation as an innovative pitching mind, to flex some muscle.

    What are your creative fixes for Minnesota's wayward bullpen?

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Marek Houston

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, SS
    The 22-year-old went 2-for-5 on Friday night, his fourth straight multi-hit game. Heading into the week, he was hitting .246/.328/.404 (.732). Four games later, he is hitting .303/.361/.447 (.808).

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Yesterday is on Molitor more than Belisle. At this point, he should only be pitching in mopup until he shows something.

     

    It's a curious bullpen this year in that they don't seem to blow many games. It's more than when they blow them, it's a spectacular failure.

     

    Yesterday is on Molitor more than Belisle. At this point, he should only be pitching in mopup until he shows something.

     

    It's a curious bullpen this year in that they don't seem to blow many games. It's more than when they blow them, it's a spectacular failure.

     

    Assuming he didn't want to go with Duffey again, who would you propose Molitor should have pitched in that inning? His options were Boshers for a second inning, Belisle, Breslow or Wimmers. I suppose he could have pushed Rogers and/or Kintzler for more than an inning.

     

    Yesterday is on Molitor more than Belisle. At this point, he should only be pitching in mopup until he shows something.

     

    It's a curious bullpen this year in that they don't seem to blow many games. It's more than when they blow them, it's a spectacular failure.

     

    Nope. It's all on the FO insisting on signing old, bad, pitchers (and injuries). Molitor can only pitch the guys he's given. He doesn't always us them they way I would, but you can't pitch the same 3-4 guys every single day. But, right now, they have legit prospects that are healthy thru June. How about calling up even 1 of them....

    Im just failing to see how some of these guys are benefiting us over seeing what we have in the minors with these prospects. It's not like the B-squad yesterday is setting the bar all that high. Seems like a no lose situation to bring some of these guys up at this point. 

     

    Nope. It's all on the FO insisting on signing old, bad, pitchers (and injuries). Molitor can only pitch the guys he's given. He doesn't always us them they way I would, but you can't pitch the same 3-4 guys every single day. But, right now, they have legit prospects that are healthy thru June. How about calling up even 1 of them....

     

    They did and he flopped. Another one will get a shot soon enough.

    I was advocating patience with both Molitor's bullpen management and the pitching staff. Things are becoming far too predictable now, however. This type of mismanagement is unfair to the Twins players who are playing hard and winning in spite of it.

     

    if Molitor can't manage a pitching staff, he needs to fall on his sword, admit he sucks at it, and let the pitching coach make the decisions during games.

     

    It's clear that there are a couple of pitchers on this team who can't pitch. let them go. Replace them with anybody who can keep an ERA around 5, which would be a huge improvement. Recent retirees, minor leaguers, converted starters, whoever. When you have a position player pitching as often as this team has, that's a screaming flashing red alarm that needs to be addressed.

     

    Maybe that other person is Jake Reed. He's been pitching pretty consistently lately in AA. 

     

    He's only had 4 appearances this year, each spaced 3 days apart, with his first and fourth outings being fairly rough. I don't think he'll be considered for MLB call-up until he at least pitches effectively on short rest. I could see him going to AAA soon though. He finished last season strong there.

     

    Assuming he didn't want to go with Duffey again, who would you propose Molitor should have pitched in that inning? His options were Boshers for a second inning, Belisle, Breslow or Wimmers. I suppose he could have pushed Rogers and/or Kintzler for more than an inning.

    First, while Duffey got 5 outs Saturday, he only needed 16 pitches to do it. And he hadn't pitched at all the two days before that.  If Duffey is in your bullpen, he should be available to pitch in that situation at this point in the season -- he's going to have to work consecutive days eventually, might as well be now.

     

    If not Duffey, then I guess I don't care if you go with Belisle to start the inning, but I think you have to have a quicker hook.  Either Duffey or a rested Rogers.

     

    Bigger picture, if Wimmers can't pitch there and isn't the long man anymore either, then he probably shouldn't be on the team.  Replace him with someone else who has the potential to be useful in that situation.  I know you frequently dismiss such notions as re-arranging deck chairs, but seriously, there's no point in having Wimmers, Heston, Boshers, and Breslow (and maybe even Belisle at this point) all together, with no trust/future but a lot of overlapping roles.  Maybe Hildenberger or Busenitz don't work out either, but they should be worth a shot over the status quo.

     

    He's only had 4 appearances this year, each spaced 3 days apart, with his first and fourth outings being fairly rough. I don't think he'll be considered for MLB call-up until he at least pitches effectively on short rest. I could see him going to AAA soon though. He finished last season strong there.

     

    Yeah that's fair. Hopefully we do see him make the move to AAA soon and pitch on back to back days. 

     

    First, while Duffey got 5 outs Saturday, he only needed 16 pitches to do it. And he hadn't pitched at all the two days before that.  If Duffey is in your bullpen, he should be available to pitch in that situation at this point in the season -- he's going to have to work consecutive days eventually, might as well be now.

     

    If not Duffey, then I guess I don't care if you go with Belisle to start the inning, but I think you have to have a quicker hook.  Either Duffey or a rested Rogers.

     

    Bigger picture, if Wimmers can't pitch there and isn't the long man anymore either, then he probably shouldn't be on the team.  Replace him with someone else who has the potential to be useful in that situation.  I know you frequently dismiss such notions as re-arranging deck chairs, but seriously, there's no point in having Wimmers, Heston, Boshers, and Breslow (and maybe even Belisle at this point) all together, with no trust/future but a lot of overlapping roles.  Maybe Hildenberger or Busenitz don't work out either, but they should be worth a shot over the status quo.

     

    I would absolutely make some bullpen changes. But that doesn't have much to do with what Molitor could do yesterday.

     

    Maybe could have pushed Duffey and/or Rogers, but that will burn you hard over the long term. No chance I would start Belisle and relieve with Duffey though.

     

    I was advocating patience with both Molitor's bullpen management and the pitching staff. Things are becoming far too predictable now, however. This type of mismanagement is unfair to the Twins players who are playing hard and winning in spite of it.

     

    if Molitor can't manage a pitching staff, he needs to fall on his sword, admit he sucks at it, and let the pitching coach make the decisions during games.

     

    It's clear that there are a couple of pitchers on this team who can't pitch. let them go. Replace them with anybody who can keep an ERA around 5, which would be a huge improvement. Recent retirees, minor leaguers, converted starters, whoever. When you have a position player pitching as often as this team has, that's a screaming flashing red alarm that needs to be addressed.

     

    I'm very curious how you think a different manager would handle this bullpen much better. And do you really know the process of how they determine which pitchers to use in which situations? I would assume it is mostly the job of the pitching coach, with plenty of input from the front office.

    Assuming he didn't want to go with Duffey again, who would you propose Molitor should have pitched in that inning? His options were Boshers for a second inning, Belisle, Breslow or Wimmers. I suppose he could have pushed Rogers and/or Kintzler for more than an inning.

    You listed six options.




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...