Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    5 Challenges The Twins Should Be Prepared To Face In 2018


    Nick Nelson

    In the history of baseball, no season has ever gone off without a hitch.

    To encounter nothing but smooth sailing over the course of six months and 162 games is about as realistic an aspiration as hitting a five-run homer.

    The better you can foresee and anticipate hurdles coming down the pipeline, the more prepared you'll be to overcome them. With this in mind, here are five predicaments I believe the Twins should be accounting for, if not counting on, in the 2018 season.

    Image courtesy of Mark J. Rebilas, USA Today

    Twins Video

    1 ) Missed Time for Miguel Sano

    Sano is currently under investigation by MLB for an alleged assault that occurred in 2015 but was revealed publicly only last month. It's unclear if he'll be suspended, but given that the league is needing to toughen up its enforcement of personal conduct violations, I'd think a 20 or even 30 game suspension is not out of the question.

    Even if Sano avoids such discipline, he's still recovering from a fairly serious surgery. Twins CBO Derek Falvey acknowledged last week that the 24-year-old "won’t necessarily be ready for full workouts when camp opens next month."

    Who knows how long it will take Sano to get back to full strength and sharpness. Even then, an offseason spent focusing on rehab – rather than the usual conditioning and mobility training – could easily render him more prone to injury.

    In each of his first two full big-league seasons, Sano has been unable to appear in even 120 games. Hopefully this is the year he makes the jump to 150, but Minnesota must be ready to proceed without him. Having Eduardo Escobar on hand helps with that, though it's probably wishful thinking to expect the same kind of production he provided down the stretch in 2017.

    Sano is also pegged for significant time at DH. Perhaps that is why I keep hearing rumblings of the team's continued interest in free agent Mike Napoli.

    2 ) Quickly Developing Questions at Closer

    If Fernando Rodney is pitching the way he did last year, when he held opponents to a .582 OPS with a 10.6 K/9 rate and 3.03 FIP, then I won't be concerned if he experiences a few early stumbles in the ninth. Hopefully Paul Molitor won't, either. However, it is far from assured that Rodney will continue at that level of performance.

    For one thing, he turns 41 in March. And for another, those numbers were all his best since 2014.

    The only thing that has been consistent for Rodney in his career is his difficulty staying in the strike zone. He's gonna walk people. You can live with that when he's missing tons of bats and holding down a .275 BABIP, but his margin for error is thin. And there are few things more frustrating – for fans, teammates, and especially the manager – than a guy coughing up a late lead because he can't throw strikes.

    In line behind Rodney are two fantastic control pitchers in Addison Reed and Trevor Hildenberger. A couple of erratic blown saves in early April will turn the heat up quickly.

    3 ) Out-of-Options Drama

    There's always an extra element at play when a fringe player comes to camp with no options remaining. By that point, the individual in question has usually been with the organization for many years. The team that drafted and developed him faces an ultimatum: bring him north or risk losing him on waivers for nothing.

    Last year, Jorge Polanco's lack of options all but guaranteed him the starting shortstop job, and (fortunately, it turns out) kept him there through a brutal midseason swoon.

    Michael Tonkin probably earned a bullpen spot out of camp solely because he was out of options. Ditto for Danny Santana as utility man. Those instances didn't work out as nicely as Polanco.

    The Twins haven't always let a lack of remaining options hold them hostage, and something tells me they won't this spring. Kennys Vargas, in particular, would seem to be at risk, and it's not entirely clear he'd even be claimed if they cut him. But, circling back to Sano's question marks, Vargas is currently the de facto slugging DH in the event of a prolonged absence.

    Ryan Pressly is also out of options, which probably won't alter the spring dynamic much (I feel he is pretty safe), but could come into play if he struggles early. With his stuff, it'll be tough to sneak him through waivers even if he's in a skid. Maybe, with their substantial bullpen depth, the Twins don't really care.

    One interesting factoid that surprised me: As far as I can tell, Kyle Gibson is NOT out of options. The Twins first optioned him in 2013, right after adding him to the 40-man, and didn't need to do so again until last May when his abysmal early performance forced the issue.

    Given that he finished 2017 so strong and will be earning upwards of $4 million this season, one might presume he'd be a lock. I have, for the most part. But this new front office has no deep attachment to him. They saw him turn it around nicely after a terrible first four months last season, but still, those four months – coupled with a 4.59 ERA in four years prior – do him no favors.

    The Twins seem to be taking a hard-line stance in arbitration with Gibson, the only player they've yet to come to terms with. All signs point to the two sides taking their dispute, over a relatively measly $350K, to a hearing.

    There's a fair chance the Twins are still going to add one or even two more starters to the mix before camp opens. I've had Gibson written in with pen but after further consideration, maybe it should be pencil.

    4 ) Backup Backstop Uncertainty

    Perhaps the team is fully confident in Mitch Garver's ability to serve as Jason Castro's primary timeshare partner. But they don't have any proof of it. Offensive questions notwithstanding – he batted only .196 in 52 plate appearances with the Twins last year, but raked in Triple-A beforehand – Garver has much to prove defensively.

    He received high marks for his receiving work in the minors but the big leagues are another story. Last year, despite spending the final six weeks of the season in Minnesota, Garver got only four starts behind the plate. Fifty total innings.

    If the Twins have similar usage planned for Jason Castro, whose frequent spellings last summer paved the way for Chris Gimenez to log career highs in plate appearances (225) and starts behind the plate (54), then No. 2 catcher is a major role on this team. Garver may very well be up to the task but at this point the Twins have done little to hedge their bets.

    5 ) Erv Regression

    Maybe he's an outlier. Maybe Ervin Santana has a particular skill set that enables his ERA to outperform his FIP (3.32 to 4.16 over the past two seasons). Perhaps he figured out something last year that enabled him to defy probability with a .247 BABIP, lowest in the American League.

    Prior to 2016, his career ERA (4.16) and FIP (4.26) were nearly identical. And his lifetime BABIP was .288, including .287 through his first two years with the Twins.

    Santana struck out 19.3% of hitters last year, ranking him 40th in the league. That's a lot of batted balls left to chance, and while he's got a tremendous defense behind him, which suited him well in 2017, it's awfully tough to sustain a .250-range BABIP. Santana has given up more than 300 home runs in his career. He turned 35 last month. He's logged nearly 2,500 innings on his right arm.

    The man was an absolute joy to watch last year, but by any objective analysis he's almost a lock to regress. It won't necessarily be a gigantic drop-off, but Minnesota can ill-afford to rely on Erv as their No. 1 starter. Right now, they are on track to do so.

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Marek Houston

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, SS
    The 22-year-old went 2-for-5 on Friday night, his fourth straight multi-hit game. Heading into the week, he was hitting .246/.328/.404 (.732). Four games later, he is hitting .303/.361/.447 (.808).

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Not fixing the rotation is like throwing a year of our window away.  You can hope some of the Rochester bound pitchers help and make it, but you might need as many as 3.  Moves need to be made here and not for bottom of rotation starters.  

    Rosario is not the player I am worried about for a major regression, maybe minor and maybe he improves.  Twins did well against the Central Division the last month, we need to do better against the rest of the league.

    This isn't he NFL or NBA where the offense is very dependent on teamwork. Would you rather have a guy that might be one of the best hitters in baseball, or Escobar, hitting? That kind of post hoc analysis is how teams and fans make bad mistakes.

    Clearly the offense would be better with him, I was just suggesting 20-30 games may not be season altering as we saw it wasn't last year. With or without Sano this team's issues are still in the rotation.

     

    I would have agreed before last year, but the team seemed to play better without Sano.

     

    Not saying the team is better off without him, just that the offense still worked quite well with him rehabbing.

    But that was because all of these players slugged over .500 from August 20th (Sano's first day out of the lineup after the shinjury) to the end of the season: Dozier, Rosario, Escobar, Polanco, Buxton. 

     

    Can you really count on that happening again over any prolonged period of time? Especially with the latter 3? 

    I think one that's missing here is a slow start for one of our three young, but no longer rookie outfielders. There's basically a 99.5% chance that our planned starting OF alignment is Rosario-Buxton-Kepler and if one or more of them struggles to find a groove out the gate it's going to be a problem for this offense...and right now the options behind them are: Zack Granite (fairly untested, did not hit much in limited action last season, and might have to start the season in AAA), Robbie Grossman (an abysmal defender), Mitch Garver (who had half the ABs of Granite and would be playing out of position), and Eduardo Escobar (who should stay in the INF).

     

    A prolonged slump by any of the starters would be concerning, especially since I don't seeing anyone exactly hammering on the door to take their jobs.

     

    Of Nick's 5, I'm most worried about Erv's decline, just because it would hurt so much. Some pitchers have a slow, gradual decline, others fall off the cliff. If it's the former, we'll be ok; if it's the latter we're in a lot of trouble.

     

    I'm not terribly concerned about the closer role. I think we have a number of reasonable options to fill it if Rodney falters, and I think we'll be able to get by with Rodney as the guy who comes in to pitch the 9th. It's also the contract that seems the easiest to move on from if it doesn't work. that's the one off the list I'm least worried about.

    Personally, I don't think the "out of options drama" is a problem.  Like you said, I think Pressly is pretty safe and I won't be at all upset if we lose Vargas to waivers.  I have two cases of fatigue when it comes to Vargas and Gibson.  Personally, I think we give Gibby a shot at a starting spot, send him to the bullpen, or cut him.  No need to set him down to AAA unless they are desperate for arms and AA doesn't have anyone worth calling up.  At this point he is what he is.

     

    Challenge #5 is what will make or break the Twins season, IMO.  Assuming a regression in Santana we need another #1 (Cobb, Darvish, etc.) or we need Berrios to take a big step this year.

     

    I'm not terribly concerned about the closer role. I think we have a number of reasonable options to fill it if Rodney falters, and I think we'll be able to get by with Rodney as the guy who comes in to pitch the 9th. It's also the contract that seems the easiest to move on from if it doesn't work. that's the one off the list I'm least worried about.

    To be clear, I'm not so much worried about being able to replace Rodney if he's blatantly terrible. They've got plenty of depth to do so. I'm worried about what happens if he's kinda bad. How long does it take the pull the plug if he's blowing a save only here and there, but more than you'd like? Will Molitor be influenced by respect for his track record, or the commitment made to him when he signed? It's always easier to make these calls from afar; much tougher in the manager's chair.

     

    Kind of discouraging to hear so many people down on Santana, as if he's dead or something. Erv led the league in complete games, was an All-Star, big innings eater, and had many votes in the Cy Young competition.

     

    A player who is overachieving isn't a bad thing, people. Even if he regresses, he's not going to turn into Mike Pelfrey. The dude's going to rack up 12-14 wins and save the bullpen a ton of work when they're tired. There are lots of teams that would drool to have a guy like that as their #2 starter. And he'll be fantastic in that role when the Twins sign Yu D.

     

    Have faith in the Twins F.O. and have some faith in Big Erv!

     

    ESan worries me the most....not because I think he will regress for sure, but because even if they sign a SP (or trade for one), his contribution is not easily replaced at all. 

    This ^^

     

    For as much love as ESan gets here (he was incredible during the 1st half last year) I think his role in reaching the WC is still understated. The Twins would've been buried by the ASG without that crazy 1st half. I realize the offense came along nicely after the break, but given the current rotation outlook we're banking on Erv repeating that crazy career half just to stay within striking distance of a WC. Scary.... 

     

    Sure, but that's not what people are posting....they are posting the Twins' offense is fine w/o him.....like he just wouldn't be missed all that much. That is very different than what you just typed.

     

    I think we all are in agreement that Sano brings fear into every at bat against other teams. He will be missed for sure. 

     

    Assuming he is on non-voluntary time off, it would also give Grossman and Vargas sometime at DH. Maybe it would give Vargas an opportunity to win some at bats later into the season... I would love to see Vargas turn into a threat.

    Edited by brightside

     

     

    I think Sano should get 20-30 games as a result of the allegations against him. I read in other posts that Sano caused problems in AA in Chatanooga and the stadium wouldn't allow female ushers to come within talking distance of the dugout.

     

    If that's true and i'm not saying its not, Sano has MUCH bigger problems than his conduct in Chattanooga.  If he is harassing female employees,fans, etc. and it's still reoccurring the Twins need to sit down with him and give him a stern ultimatum.  Knock it off or your toast.    




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...