Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins Minor League Coverage

    What's Next For Kohl Stewart?


    Cody Christie
    Image courtesy of Kelly McGlohon-27OUTSBASEBALL.COM

    Twins Video

    Pitching was the theme of players added to the Twins 40-man roster earlier this week. Stephen Gonsalves, Zack Littell and Lewis Thorpe were all added as the new front office looks to lock in young pitching. Even with a focus on pitching, one name was left off the list.

    Former first-round pick Kohl Stewart was not added to the team’s 40-man roster. This means he will be available in next month’s Rule 5 Draft. It’s been a tumultuous Twins tenure for Stewart and now his future is in doubt. So, what’s next for Kohl Stewart?

    Background

    The Twins took Stewart with the fourth pick of the 2013 MLB Draft and signed him for $4.5 million. He had the chance to play quarterback on a Division I scholarship but he turned it down to pitch professionally. Even the major prospect gurus took notice of Stewart and his high ceiling. All three major prospect rankings had him as a top-55 prospect before the 2014 season. Leading into 2015, MLB had him at 36 and Baseball Prospectus had him at 28. Things were looking good for the young Texas hurler.

    Roller Coaster Ride

    Stewart spent all of 2015 in Fort Myers where he was almost three years younger than the competition. He didn’t take the next step like most people had hoped. He allowed multiple runs in 16 of his 22 appearances and compiled a 3.20 ERA with a 1.38 WHIP. Prospect writers had hoped Stewart would start striking out more batters. He only struck out 71 in 129.1 innings.

    The 2016 season saw some minor improvements for Stewart. His ERA dropped to 2.61 during a return trip through the Florida State League. After he was bumped up to Double-A, his ERA rose to 3.03 but he posted a 1.47 WHIP. His strikeouts per nine improved from 4.9 to 5.7 but it still wasn’t nearly what experts had hoped he would be able to reach.

    Stewart has missed time throughout his career with minor shoulder issues. Since he split time as an amateur between football and baseball, he needed to spend time learning how to pitch. Any time he was missing due to injury was taking away from learning the art of pitching.

    During the 2017 season, Stewart spent almost the entire season at Double-A. As a 22-year old, he struggled to the tune of a 4.09 ERA and a 1.52 WHIP. His strikeouts per nine went up to 6.3 but his walks per nine also rose to 5.0. All of his appearances came as a starter but he was limited to 17 starts, the fewest since he started pitching in full-season leagues. He missed almost two months due to tendinitis in a knee.

    What’s Next?

    Overall, he has shown the ability to coax a lot of ground balls. His strikeout promise from when the Twins drafted him has never come to fruition. He also continues to be very young for the levels where he has pitched. Stewart was the youngest player to make an appearance with Rochester this season. However, the strikeout numbers many thought he would grow into have never shown up. A team could take him in the Rule 5 Draft and try and hide him in their bullpen for the entire season. If he remains in the organization, even the Twins might decide to move him to the bullpen.

    A once promising future has gotten a little cloudy over the last couple of seasons. What do you think should be expected of Stewart? Will a team take him in the Rule 5 Draft? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion.


    Interested in learning more about the Minnesota Twins' top prospects? Check out our comprehensive top prospects list that includes up-to-date stats, articles and videos about every prospect, scouting reports, and more!

    View Twins Top Prospects

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Yasser Mercedes

    Cedar Rapids Kernels - A+, OF
    On Thursday in the Fall League, Mercedes went 2-for-4 with his first double and his first homer run of the AFL season.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    While Kohl Stewart does have the potential too be a regrettable loss, we left him of the 40-man for a reason. And it would plain stupid to just let him go through the Rule 5 Draft. He's a 1st rounder!!! Whose stock hasn't taken too big of a hit. Hopefully all this means is that Falvine is planning to deal Stewart like the A's dealt Jaycob Brugman to Orioles (MLBTR). In the same MLBTR article, it was also mentioned that the Twins are exploring trades for relievers such as Raisel Iglesias, Brad Hand, Alex Colome, and Justin Wilson.

     

    Although I've said this many times, I still believe that Brad Hand would be the best option for the Twins, and would fit perfectly in our bullpen (another lefty besides Rogers) and Minnesota (hometown is Chaska). In the comment section of the MLBTR article it's mentioned many times that Nick Gordon would probably be the center piece in a deal for any of those 4 relievers.  So I believe a package of Gordon, Stewart, and Felix Jorge would be an offer that San Diego would find hard to refuse be they are in dire need of a SS and needs young starting pitching (like every other team in the league).

    I would say the one exception I would make would be a clearly ready college arm - Price and Strasburg were about as surefire as you can get, Verlander quite close too.

     

    Kershaw, like he is in many ways, is an exception to a rule. And even he was a #7 pick. What's interesting too, is that 5 college arms were selected before him that year and none stuck as a starter (though a couple became good relievers). The college bat taken ahead was Longoria.

    It does seem that college pitchers generally have done better than HS, but it’s hard to draw a firm rule. Bumgarner was pick #10 out of high school. Lots of college pitchers have been bad, also, including Mark Appel. If there’s any pattern that I’ve noticed, it’s that it’s bad to be a pitcher selected by the Orioles. Other than that, with all the changes happening in scouting and development, I wouldn’t draw rules about drafting based on data more than a few years old and recent data is a lot of SSS.

    My only complaint in all of this is that the guys THE TWINS DIDN'T PROTECT were all valuable tradechips during the summer

    A Kohl Stewart thread isn't really the place to debate a bigger-picture thing like this, but I think you've said it before, and I don't understand why. Other teams can see the 40-man dilemma approaching for such players, just as we can.

    I felt like Stewart had to have a big year in 2016 to regain his prospect status. It's been 2 years and he has slightly improved. He's a bust and has been for a while. If he wasn't a top pick he wouldn't of even been hardly mentioned by any of us.

    Not that I don't wish him well and all, but I can't really see any reason to add him to the 40 man roster at this time. Seems like a good decision by the front office. What's the saying in poker? Don't throw good money after bad money.

    I like the new direction and wish Kohl Stewart well whether it be with the Twins or another club.  Twins have changed from pretenders to contenders, and with this change the Twins need major league ready talent.  None of the players left off are regarded as sure things, so you take the chance.  Only downside will be if the Twins do not spend money this winter to improve the club and fill those holes. Players like Slegers were regarded closer to helping the big team than Stewart.  We may disagree, but I do not mind this direction.

    I hope we are coming to the end of 30 years of failed pitching development, which starts with who you draft.

    One can only hope. They have a lot riding on Leach and Enlow but it will be several seasons before they know what these guys will end up being. Cautiously optimistic.

    Edited by laloesch

    What your looking at is a second coming of Todd Ritchie. Another Texas high schooler who was overhyped and drafted number one by the Twins. Todd couldn't strike anyone out either (5.6/9). When the Twins gave up on him he actually went to a bad Pittsburgh team and won 15 games. The next year the league pretty much had him figured out. But he did parlay that into about 7 million dollars. I'm not going to lose any sleep over losing Kohl Stewart.

     

     

    While Kohl Stewart does have the potential too be a regrettable loss, we left him of the 40-man for a reason. And it would plain stupid to just let him go through the Rule 5 Draft. He's a 1st rounder!!! Whose stock hasn't taken too big of a hit. Hopefully all this means is that Falvine is planning to deal Stewart like the A's dealt Jaycob Brugman to Orioles (MLBTR). In the same MLBTR article, it was also mentioned that the Twins are exploring trades for relievers such as Raisel Iglesias, Brad Hand, Alex Colome, and Justin Wilson.

     

    Although I've said this many times, I still believe that Brad Hand would be the best option for the Twins, and would fit perfectly in our bullpen (another lefty besides Rogers) and Minnesota (hometown is Chaska). In the comment section of the MLBTR article it's mentioned many times that Nick Gordon would probably be the center piece in a deal for any of those 4 relievers.  So I believe a package of Gordon, Stewart, and Felix Jorge would be an offer that San Diego would find hard to refuse be they are in dire need of a SS and needs young starting pitching (like every other team in the league).

     

    Think trades for Colome or Hand would take a higher end pitching prospect than Stewart to go with Gordon.  Maybe need to add Thorpe or Littell..most likely a deal breaker.   Wilson tailed off a bit with the Cubs late this year so he could probably be had for less.

     

    I would take him in an instant if I was a bad team. Put him in the bullpen and see what his stuff looks like.

    Same here, but I put Stewart's chances of sticking on a 25-man roster for a full season very low. Like

     

    Which raises the next question: does the new front office like Stewart enough to take him back or would they work out a deal with the claiming team?

     

    Same here, but I put Stewart's chances of sticking on a 25-man roster for a full season very low. Like <10% low.

     

    Which raises the next question: does the new front office like Stewart enough to take him back or would they work out a deal with the claiming team?

    I would hope they would take him back, but a prospect that would not have to be added to the 40 man for a couple of years with upside could be fine with me.

     

    I would hope they would take him back, but a prospect that would not have to be added to the 40 man for a couple of years with upside could be fine with me.

    I mean, probably. My primary question is whether the organization is so down on him that they'll take anything for him just to move on.

    I'm over Stewart. I've been hoping he could put it together, but doubting it more each day. If I was a bad team, why would I want a guy that doesn't miss bats and sits in the low 90s with a straight fastball? He won't get claimed. Jury is out on him. Unless he finds more bite to his slider or a cutter, he is destined to fizzle out.

    I'm over Stewart. I've been hoping he could put it together, but doubting it more each day. If I was a bad team, why would I want a guy that doesn't miss bats and sits in the low 90s with a straight fastball? He won't get claimed. Jury is out on him. Unless he finds more bite to his slider or a cutter, he is destined to fizzle out.

    I would try him in the bullpen. Might get a couple more ticks and figure this guy out. Definitely would be worth a look

    I want to offer a word of caution. Many people were saying we had become contenders after the 2015 season (praising Ryan for a super quick rebuild). Then 2016 happened. With our pitching, I am not sure we can say we are out of the woods yet because we had a good season. We could EASILY end up in the 70 win area next season.

    Edited by jimmer



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...