The Twins' Greatest Players: Stalwarts & Beloved

[Cody Christie]

The Sporting News has been examining the 140 greatest baseball players of all time through an unconventional approach. Rather than ranking every player on a single list, the publication has divided its selections into 14 positionless rooms, each “representing and articulating varying archetypes of greatness.” Each room contains 10 players whose careers share a common thread, offering a different way to consider what makes a player historically significant. 

The publication explained its philosophy by stating, “Our ‘rooms’ serve not only to honor the game’s greatest players, but to contextualize their standing in baseball history — for better or worse.”

From a Minnesota Twins perspective, this series identifies two players for each of the 14 rooms. Some former Twins might fit into different categories when viewed through a national lens, but their careers still connect to the themes behind each room. The goal is to explore how these players shaped the franchise and why their contributions deserve to be remembered.

This installment focuses on four players who left lasting marks on Twins history in different ways. Brad Radke and Jim Perry made reliability a defining part of their careers, while Tony Oliva and Torii Hunter developed connections with fans that extended well beyond the baseball diamond.

Stalwarts

The Sporting News describes its Stalwarts as players who made excellence routine. Their careers were defined by steadiness and certainty rather than a handful of spectacular seasons. These players became dependable fixtures, providing the type of production their teams could count on year after year.

For the Twins, Brad Radke and Jim Perry fit this category. Radke became a reliable rotation anchor during Minnesota's return to contention in the early 2000s, while Perry established himself as one of the franchise's most dependable starters during the late 1960s and early 1970s.

Brad Radke

Radke spent his entire 12-year major league career with the Twins, making him one of the most recognizable players from the franchise's transition from the struggling teams of the 1990s to its run of division titles in the following decade. Radke finished his career with 148 wins, 139 losses and a 4.22 ERA across 2,451 innings. He made one All-Star appearance, in 1998, but his career value extended far beyond that single honor. He was the type of pitcher who gave Minnesota a chance to win whenever he took the mound.

His best season came in 1997, when Radke went 20-10 with a 3.87 ERA. He won 12 consecutive decisions at one point and finished third in American League Cy Young Award voting. The accomplishment was especially impressive because Minnesota finished with only 68 wins that season. Radke accounted for nearly one-third of the team's victories.

Radke's career became defined by what followed. From 1998 through 2001, he made between 32 and 34 starts each season and won between 12 and 15 games annually. He routinely surpassed 200 innings, giving the Twins a dependable presence at the front of their rotation even as the organization worked to rebuild its roster.

He wasn't a power pitcher who overwhelmed hitters with triple-digit fastballs. Radke relied on command, an effective changeup and his ability to keep hitters off balance. When opposing batters adjusted to one pitch, he found ways to adjust in return. His approach allowed him to remain productive even as baseball's offensive environment changed.

Radke became particularly important as Minnesota developed into a contender. The Twins won their division in 2002, 2003, 2004 and 2006, and Radke was a central part of those teams. His experience provided stability for a rotation that helped the franchise return to the postseason after years of struggles.

His career ended after the 2006 season, but his reputation as a dependable starter remains part of his legacy. Radke never won a Cy Young Award or received the national attention given to some of his contemporaries. He did, however, provide Minnesota with more than a decade of consistent starting pitching.

That makes him a natural fit for the Stalwarts room. Radke's greatness was not built on a few spectacular moments. It came from repeatedly taking the ball, delivering competitive outings and giving his team a chance to win.

Jim Perry

Jim Perry's Twins career included one of the franchise's most significant individual pitching achievements, but his broader body of work also makes him a strong candidate for the Stalwarts category. Perry pitched in the major leagues from 1959 through 1975, compiling 215 wins and 174 losses. He spent time with Cleveland and Detroit in addition to Minnesota, but his most celebrated seasons came with the Twins.

Perry became a regular member of Minnesota's rotation in the late 1960s and emerged as one of the American League's most reliable starters. He won 20 games in 1969, finishing with a 20-6 record, before producing an even better campaign the following season.

In 1970, Perry went 24-12 with a 3.04 ERA and earned the American League Cy Young Award. Minnesota won 98 games and captured the AL West title, and Perry played a significant role in the club's success. He became the first Twins pitcher to win the Cy Young Award and one of the most accomplished starters in franchise history.

Although that Cy Young season stands out, Perry's career was about more than one award. He had already demonstrated his ability to handle a heavy workload, and his back-to-back 20-win seasons established him as a dependable option for a team regularly competing for division titles.

Perry's accomplishments also placed him in a unique baseball family. His younger brother, Gaylord Perry, would win two Cy Young Awards of his own, making them the only brothers to receive the honor.

For Minnesota, Jim Perry represents an important era in franchise history. The Twins were building a winning identity in the American League, and Perry helped give them a dependable rotation presence during that period. His 1970 award offered a defining moment, but the consistency that preceded and surrounded that achievement is what makes him a Stalwart.

Beloved

The Sporting News describes its Beloved room as a group of players who built a lasting connection with fans. Their greatness was forged through that relationship, creating a legacy that extended beyond statistics and individual awards.

The Twins have had several players who became fan favorites, but Tony Oliva and Torii Hunter stand out. Oliva's relationship with Minnesota has spanned generations, while Hunter's energy, defensive brilliance and personality made him one of the defining figures of the franchise's return to contention in the 2000s.

Tony Oliva

Oliva's connection with Minnesota began when he arrived from Cuba in the early 1960s. He quickly established himself as one of baseball's premier hitters, winning the American League Rookie of the Year Award in 1964 and capturing batting titles in each of his first two full major league seasons.

Oliva spent his entire 15-year playing career with the Twins, finishing with a .304 batting average, 220 home runs, 947 RBI and 1,917 hits. He was selected to eight consecutive All-Star Games from 1964 through 1971 and won three American League batting titles. His offensive production helped Minnesota capture the 1965 American League pennant, the franchise's first since moving to Minnesota.

His career might have produced even greater numbers if not for a series of knee injuries. Oliva missed most of the 1972 season and spent his final years primarily as a designated hitter before retiring after the 1976 campaign. Despite those setbacks, he became one of the most respected players of his generation.

For Twins fans, Oliva's legacy goes beyond his playing statistics. Known affectionately as “Tony O,” he remained connected to the organization long after his final at-bat. He worked as a coach, served as an ambassador for the franchise and became a familiar presence at Target Field and community events throughout Twins Territory.

His long-awaited election to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2021, followed by his induction in 2022, was an emotional moment for Minnesota fans who had spent decades arguing that he deserved baseball's highest honor. Oliva had remained a loyal member of the organization, sharing stories, signing autographs and connecting with generations of supporters. 

That bond makes Oliva an obvious choice for the Beloved room. His playing career gave fans plenty to celebrate, but his warmth and loyalty helped turn him into something more than a former star. He became an enduring representative of the franchise and the community it serves.

Oliva's story also demonstrates how a player's relationship with fans can grow long after his playing career ends. His Hall of Fame induction validated his accomplishments on the field, but his place in Minnesota sports history had been secure for years.

Torii Hunter

Hunter brought an unmistakable energy to the Twins. Whether he was tracking down a ball in center field, celebrating with teammates or interacting with fans, Hunter played with a personality that made him one of the franchise's most recognizable figures.

Minnesota selected Hunter in the first round of the 1993 MLB Draft, and he eventually developed into one of baseball's premier defensive outfielders. He won nine Gold Glove Awards during his career and earned five All-Star selections. His defensive reputation became a defining part of the Twins' identity as the franchise returned to contention in the early 2000s.

Hunter's breakout season came in 2001, when he hit 27 home runs, drove in 92 runs and won his first Gold Glove. He became an All-Star in 2002, the same year he made one of the most memorable defensive plays in baseball history by robbing Barry Bonds of a home run during the All-Star Game.

That catch helped introduce Hunter to a national audience, but his connection with Twins fans had already been growing. His enthusiasm on the field matched his outgoing personality off it, and he became a central figure during Minnesota's run of four division titles between 2002 and 2006.

Hunter's production also made him much more than a defensive specialist. He hit 192 home runs and drove in 711 runs in 1,234 games with Minnesota during his two stints with the club. His combination of power, speed and elite defense made him a valuable contributor throughout his time in a Twins uniform.

After leaving Minnesota following the 2007 season, Hunter spent time with the Los Angeles Angels and Detroit Tigers before returning to the Twins for one final season in 2015. His return gave fans an opportunity to reconnect with a player who helped define an important era in franchise history. Hunter announced his retirement that October after 19 major league seasons.

His legacy in Minnesota is about more than nine Gold Gloves or five All-Star selections. Hunter was a leader during the club's resurgence, a fan favorite who played with visible joy and a recognizable face who represented the franchise throughout the region.

Hunter fits the Beloved category because his relationship with fans became inseparable from his baseball identity. His energy and personality helped make him a favorite in the clubhouse and in the stands, and his return in 2015 underscored the connection that remained even after years away.

Four Different Paths to Greatness

Radke, Perry, Oliva and Hunter represent different sides of Twins history, but they all left lasting legacies.

Radke and Perry demonstrated the value of dependable starting pitching. Radke provided Minnesota with a reliable presence through its rise from rebuilding team to division winner, while Perry helped anchor a rotation during one of the franchise's earliest successful eras.

Oliva and Hunter built their legacies through a different kind of consistency. Both delivered memorable on-field performances, but their connection with fans and their continued association with the organization made them more than former players.

The Sporting News' room concept offers a useful reminder that baseball greatness can take many forms. Some players are remembered for historic peaks, while others build their reputations through dependable production or lasting relationships with the people who watch them play.

For the Twins, all four players belong in the conversation. Their careers show how consistency can become a form of greatness and how a player's bond with fans can last long after his final game.

---

Who else should be added to these rooms? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

Image courtesy of Jason Bridge-USA TODAY Sports (Hunter), National Baseball Hall of Fame (Oliva)

View full article

[HerbieFan]

Radke getting 30 decision in 1997 must make analytics nerds cringe.  I love Tori but have always been a tiny bit confused why Twins fans adore a guy who left for more money (Hunter) and vilify a guy who left only because he was traded away (AJ).

[1985Fan]

Puckett and Killebrew left off the list of beloved players?! Hunter does not belong, but Tony O is deserving. Killebrew is the all-time greatest Twin, HOFer, and broadcast Twins games after retirement. I believe he was part of the broadcast team during the 1987 WS season. Puckett won two WS championships for crying out loud. How much more beloved can you get between Killebrew and Puckett? 
I don’t hate Hunter, but he didn’t do anything special during his time in the Twins uniform. A good player that decided to leave for more money. Came back for one nice season, but big deal. 

[IndianaTwin]

1 hour ago, 1985Fan said:

Puckett and Killebrew left off the list of beloved players?! Hunter does not belong, but Tony O is deserving. Killebrew is the all-time greatest Twin, HOFer, and broadcast Twins games after retirement. I believe he was part of the broadcast team during the 1987 WS season. Puckett won two WS championships for crying out loud. How much more beloved can you get between Killebrew and Puckett? 
I don’t hate Hunter, but he didn’t do anything special during his time in the Twins uniform. A good player that decided to leave for more money. Came back for one nice season, but big deal. 

The premise is that each player can only be used once in the series. Killebrew and Puckett have already been used. 

[1985Fan]

1 hour ago, IndianaTwin said:

The premise is that each player can only be used once in the series. Killebrew and Puckett have already been used. 

I found the previous “Twins Greatest Players” post that put Killebrew and Puckett (along with Carew and Mauer) in the Inner Circle and Immortals categories. Ok, I can agree with that. I still say Hunter does not belong in the Beloved category. 

[Linus]

Jim Perry with 215 wins - impressive. I didn’t recall that. He and Radke were great choices as is Tony O. Who is more beloved than Tony? Hunter was a really good player but I wouldn’t say beloved.