Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    105
  • comments
    1,104
  • views
    186,612

Are Twins pinching future pennies?


Twins Video

I was just talking with a "friend in the know". And now my distrust of the Pohlads went to a whole new level. Of course yes I am a conspiracy theorist!! and no none of these thoughts have been proven factual, or even accurate, BUT  when do we need provable facts to form opinions?

I have always factored in the potential of a 2027 work stoppage/lockout when proposing hypothetical trades, and how a potential lockout would impact the cost of players under contract.  One thing I never thought about is... what happens to players currently NOT under contract?

Am I the only one who has wondered why the Twins, claiming to be buyers and wanting to contend keep promoting lesser quality players from AAA, when there are future core pieces ready or near ready???  Of course each of Culpepper and Jenkins have had some injuries slowing their march to the big leagues. Along with Emmanual Rodriguez... although he is not actually back playing yet so a bit of a different story there.

Aaron Sabato has been raking pretty much all year, but really not a place for him with Bell at DH and Caratini and Lewis getting reps at 1B.  and at 27, he may not be a huge future core piece, so I am not questioning that move.  Wallner has been raking (and I have always said he is a notorious slow starter btu always comes on as the year goes on.  But again this is not the type of conspiracy I am now buying into. Where would he play? with Larnach have a good season, Clemens and Keaschall getting OF reps etc.  Wallner is already on an MLB contract and accruing service time.

But what about the first 2 mentioned. They both play positions where we could use a boost, either short term or long term.  with Buxton out again someone who can play CF fits the bill. Keaschall has been decent but Jenkins is the future. Kriedler at SS just isn't major league caliber while Culpepper is a potential future core player back and playing well at AAA.

Are the Twins actually manipulating potential service time on these guys (and maybe a couple others) to protect against a potential lock out NEXT YEAR?  While at the same time claiming to be "buyers" and "committed to winning"? My buddy has said that players will actually get credit for service time even during a lockout/work stoppage. While this in theory cannot be known as next year regardless would be under a new CBA which hasnt been negotiated yet, so you cannot say for certain how players will be treated. But it makes sense that the MLBPA will push for players getting credit, especially if it is an owner imposed lockout. Also, it is the ONLY thing that makes sense as to why the Twins continue to call up people other than the likes of Jenkins, Culpepper, etc.

Why would the cheap Twins want to start the clock on high end prospects, only to watch that clock tick by without them actually playing in games next year? It makes more sense to keep them in the minors to get a fresh clock on them next year and protect against losing controllable time in a lockout. If there is NOT a lock out for some reason, then they get to just start the clock next year anyways.

This could make "good" "business sense" but this is what CHEAP teams do, not what WINNING team do, and "winning" is what the Twins are claiming to be focused on.

Am I just conspiracy crazy? or could this be an actual reason why we are not calling up these guys?

In theory, you could make the "who are you going to take out of the lineup?"  question for Jenkins, with Larnach and Clemens playing well,  and up until now Buxton playing, and even with Buxton out you COULD say Keaschall and his OF development are equally vital.  But our SS position???  that makes zero sense!!!

Can you either talk me off the ledge or push me please?

8 Comments


Recommended Comments

Culpepper was hurt and just came back and hasn’t played in the field since coming back. Jenkins I do think is close.

If this is September 1, and both of them are playing well and not hurt and also haven’t been promoted then I can see your point maybe. But at the same time, no one knows for sure what the next cba will include. So trying to manipulate time when we don’t know how time will be counted doesn’t make sense to me 

tony&rodney

Posted

The irrational jabs against the Pohlads are pointless and off base. There were mistakes made, mostly comments that were poorly framed and ill-timed. The collapse of the regional networks hurt small and medium market clubs. I'm not sure how the loss of $30-50 million in revenue can be ignored. The player acquisition decisions are like 99.9% on the front office. The manager and coaching staff do not pick the team. They do communicate their thoughts.

Neither of Jenkins nor Culpepper are ready right now for regular playing time. It does seem possible that they are called up in August dependent on their play and the needs of the MLB club. If anything, Tom Pohlad is probably wondering about them too. He isn't likely to push forward comments and sound like a fool. The Twins are being managed and run differently this year. Perhaps not to the level many would desire but there has been change. 

Brandon

Posted

I doubt the Pohlads are holding anyone back.  There is money to be made in the Playoffs if they can get in and the excitement.  not to mention the increase in attendance if the Twins are in the race and close, especially if they are slightly ahead soon.  

Tom desperately wants to make the playoffs even if it’s the last spot in a weak AL. Now they are pinching Pennie’s along the way as a small market team should do. They aren’t throwing away assets or years. Both Culpepper and Jenkins in a full season could be potential rookie of the years which has value. Zoll stated they were willing to bring rookies up, now the question is who? Is it Culpepper and Jenkins- or Rodriguez and Mendez?

laloesch

Posted

On 7/31/2026 at 11:22 AM, tony&rodney said:

The irrational jabs against the Pohlads are pointless and off base. There were mistakes made, mostly comments that were poorly framed and ill-timed. The collapse of the regional networks hurt small and medium market clubs. I'm not sure how the loss of $30-50 million in revenue can be ignored. The player acquisition decisions are like 99.9% on the front office. The manager and coaching staff do not pick the team. They do communicate their thoughts.

Neither of Jenkins nor Culpepper are ready right now for regular playing time. It does seem possible that they are called up in August dependent on their play and the needs of the MLB club. If anything, Tom Pohlad is probably wondering about them too. He isn't likely to push forward comments and sound like a fool. The Twins are being managed and run differently this year. Perhaps not to the level many would desire but there has been change. 

There is truth to this statement.  The small and medium market clubs got PUNISHED by the regional tv and streaming deal collapses.  That's part of the reason I think there is a push for a cap and floor.  This level of spending (right now) is probably the ceiling the Twins are willing to spend unless something changes.  Which again is why I'm not certain why they hung onto Ryan Jeffers and Joe Ryan.  Neither is going to be resigned.  They should have gone for the prospects now and let the chips fall where they may after the 2027 labor strike and whatever deal comes out of that so this team can rebuild.  To me this trading for these relievers while noble is just a band aid fix and I honestly don't think it's going to be enough to get this team into the playoffs.  The offense is flat, and the Joe Ryan looks totally gassed. 

dxpavelka

Posted

22 hours ago, laloesch said:

There is truth to this statement.  The small and medium market clubs got PUNISHED by the regional tv and streaming deal collapses.  That's part of the reason I think there is a push for a cap and floor.  This level of spending (right now) is probably the ceiling the Twins are willing to spend unless something changes.  Which again is why I'm not certain why they hung onto Ryan Jeffers and Joe Ryan.  Neither is going to be resigned.  They should have gone for the prospects now and let the chips fall where they may after the 2027 labor strike and whatever deal comes out of that so this team can rebuild.  To me this trading for these relievers while noble is just a band aid fix and I honestly don't think it's going to be enough to get this team into the playoffs.  The offense is flat, and the Joe Ryan looks totally gassed. 

Can't fault them for taking a shot.  Had they blown it up nobody would have been happy either.

Eris

Posted

I would add to this that Jenkins doesn’t need to be added to the 40 man roster until next December. Adding him this year reduces flexibility for the off-season. The Twins have 5 pitchers on the 60 day IL. 

tony&rodney

Posted

1 hour ago, Eris said:

I would add to this that Jenkins doesn’t need to be added to the 40 man roster until next December. Adding him this year reduces flexibility for the off-season. The Twins have 5 pitchers on the 60 day IL. 

You are correct. If Walker Jenkins has not been added to the 40 well before that time, the Twins have a major problem. 

A quick look at the current 40 roster shows six (6) players on the 60 day IL. Even after adding back those players, the Twins should not have any problem getting down to 34 or less players should they wish to make those calls. Right now, the Twins can IL Kyler Fedko for 60 days to open a spot on the 40 roster. Spots on the Twins roster are not exactly dear at this point in time.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...