I prefer a "baseball guy" to run the organization too, but even if we use MacPhail as the template, there might be issues in what we consider a "baseball guy." As far as I can tell, the MacPhail clan's only on-field experience is Andy's stint playing DIII ball. He got started in the business because of his dad, who got into the business because of his dad. Patriarch, Larry, was a lawyer who bought a minor league team for what seems like just a hobby. If we're being critical (and I'm really just playing devil's advocate) the only reason anyone would think of the MacPhail's as baseball people is because of generations of nepotism started by a rich lawyer who went to law school with Branch Rickey (who would also then not be a "baseball guy"?) So along those lines, would Bill Smith's kids automatically be considered "baseball guys?"