Rosterman
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
6,758 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by Rosterman
-
DET 4, MIN 3: Twins Fail to Execute in Extras
Rosterman replied to Jamie Cameron's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Having a runner start at second has to be a different strategy for a bullpen arm. You like it if you have a chance to match or tie in your bottom half. You hate it if you can't get that runner home. Stashak was all over the place, but still struck out the side. Go figure. Twins batters are still swinging too freely (or not at all). I keep thinking e would be better served with Arraez at second and Polanco as the all-around guy. Willians is a force. You gotta run with the guy until the other other teams catch up on watching film of his at bats. Sano...can be bat ninth? -
MIN 15, DET 6: Cruz Leads Trouncing of Tigers
Rosterman replied to Nate Palmer's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Well, he bullpen is rested, although I would've kept Dobnak to pair with Happ. You could push him today for the third inning because of the lead, but could've also used Thielbar in this no-pressure situation to get him into a game. So Rocco likes players that can play a variety of positions, I sense. -
It's Not Time to Worry About Alex Colomé
Rosterman replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Yeah, with a three-run lead you take the easy out as a double play would be hard to turn. That the Kepler could've been an out...well.... I would've walked Shaw to load the basis and have a forceout at any base. Considering the weak groundout...... The killer was the Twins striking out 17 times. And two of our best contact hitters couldn't put the ball in play with a runner starting the tenth on second base. -
4 Call-Up Options Should Josh Donaldson Miss Time
Rosterman replied to Matthew Taylor's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I would move Sano to third and have Rooker play first base. -
Twins Finalize Opening Day Roster
Rosterman replied to Seth Stohs's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Garlick has a hot bat, so see if he can give the Twins additional power. Feel bad for Rooker. But for now, we hove to hope that the lineup hits much better than Sano, Buxton, Kepler, Simmons, Cave this spring. Willians means Garver can also play in the !B or DH mix. I'm curious to see Happ's first outing. -
Why Isn't Dobnak in the Starting Rotation?
Rosterman replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
THEY JUST SIGNED HIM TO A FIVE-YEAR CONTRACT! Here's hoping he's not another Joe Mays! Or Nick Blackburn! -
I still think Happ is on the bubble for opening on the DL because of the late spring training from COVID. Thielbar COULD be on the bubble. He would go thru waievrs and could resign with the Twins. Stashak could be optioned out. Colina will be on the 60-day, opening a roster spot. The Twins could easily add both Law and Waddell. If either falters, there is Stashak and others in the minors. But both could be pleasant roster surprises. In the field, Cave wins out because he can play center and also bats left. Garlick is the reserve if something happens to Cruz or Sano. I'm hoping Duffey has just been playing around with the ball on the mound this spring!
-
Why Isn't Dobnak in the Starting Rotation?
Rosterman replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I'm thinking Happ might open the season on the DL, using his late start from COVID as an excuse, buying the Twins a couple of starts for Dobnak. Waiting to see. Rumor also ahs Colina going on the 60-day (which is whyy he hasn't been optioned to the minors yet. -
Well, Lance McCullers just signed a long-term contract to stay in the Astros rotation through the 2026 season at cost of $85 million and a limited no-trade clause. https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/03/astros-lance-mccullers-jr-agree-to-extension.html The Twins still can take a hard looksee at Berrios for the 2021 season and not have to make any drastic move until the off-season. Is this a contract those Jose would sign to remain a Twin? Can the Twins roll-the-ball and get him for less? Do we feel he is a long-term answer to be the anchor of the Twins starting rotation going forward as others join him in the future (Duran, Balazovic)?
-
Rooker would've been the odd man out. And the guy showed last year and this spring that he deserves at least a chance. Rooker could also fit into the Twins longterm plays, as a potential fulltime DH, or an option for first base protection who can also play the outfield. If Rooker didn't make the team this year, he would be gone from the Twins organization in short order. So spring stats can count. Plus the role a player might play for the club (why Cave gets chosen over Garlick for the moment). Now about WiIllians.....
-
Twins 2021 Position Analysis: Relief Pitcher
Rosterman replied to Nick Nelson's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The joy is we may have a rotation that can push the six inning, if not the 7 inning call. Yes, Odorizzi and his five inning stints was shorted last year. All those fine arms at AAAA-level at Rochester, but the Twins 40-man is so tight. There is little wiggle room - an outfielder, an infielder, and perhaps two pitching arms that would get snatched by another team if run thru waivers. You don't hope that any planned arms blowup and get released, but aside from 60-daying someone, there isn't a lot of roster moves on the horizon for Twinsland beyond those already on the 40-man. Can Anderson, Colina and Chalmers be the first three to depend on for bullpen relief? Otherwise the 40-man is full of rotation arms-to-be in Smeltzer, Dobnak, Thorpe, Duran, Balazovic, Ober - any who would not refuse a call to the majors to pitch and inning or two. As can see, not a lot of waiverable names in this list to replace with Hamilton or others. Usually it is nice to have one spot that you play the up-and-down waiver-wire game with. (Trying to remember, do players have to stay down NOW for a certain number of days, or remain on the 40-man)?- 23 replies
-
- taylor rogers
- alex colome
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Alex Kirilloff Optioned to Alternate Training Site
Rosterman replied to Tom Froemming's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I actually think Cave/Rooker is an upgrade over Rosario at this point. It is Rooker's job to now play himself out of the Twin organization. Rooker can get the at bats and the Twins will have to make a hard decision on Cruz as the season plays out, and look closely at the future potential that might still exist for Sano. If Rooker produces, he is a fine luxury to have. Considering names like Larnach and Kirilloff are in the wings and pretty sure bets to play as well as anyone else the Twins have patrolling the outfield. If Alex had shined in spring training, Rooker might've become the next Paul Sorrento or Michael Restovich of the Twins, leaving and never getting a really strong chance to shine. Of course, he may still be - but I am happy to see him get a chance to become a Twins mainstay. I would almost go with Garlick over Cave. Almost. Kyle can go to the minors, so that is probably what will happen. Cave can play center instead of Kepler. I do always go with the argument to better have guys playing everday who can come up and play in the majors, rather than have reserves sitting on the bench and them moving into the starting role. They are usually reserves for a reason. -
Lewis Thorpe fourth option granted
Rosterman replied to Otto von Ballpark's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Then he makes the team. Who goes down, Dobnak (to start everyday) or possibly Stashak? -
You shudder looking at those spring training numbers. Sano, Kepler and Buxton all playing dismal. Yet you gotta keep them. The reason to keep Cave is that he is the backup for centerfield? Kepler can play center in a pinch. Otherwise, you jettison Cave and keep Garlick. Rooker, too...who can backup first base and DH (with Garver). You go with hot bats sometimes, especially with players on the margin. If you lose Cave, if Garlick doesn't work out, you have Broxton. Willians has played himself into a roster spot. All-around utility guy. Will allow the Twins to get Garver at bats at 1B or DH if need be All I can say is Kepler needs some work, again. And don't bat him lead-off until he figures out what is happening to his swing! This has to be the year that Sano, Buxton and Kepler show their worth to the organization. Kirilloff needs to play everyday, as does Larnach...and both should shine at AAA. What to do with Nick Gordon!
- 115 replies
-
- alex kirilloff
- rocco baldelli
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
If both were offered back to the Twins in the next week, would you take them back? What are the chances that either would get a call to the majors this year? And would they be bonifide candidates to be added to the 40-man in 2022. Of course, both should be taken back, given a chance to shine, and at the very very least would be tradebait add-ons, especially Baddoo. If Buxton is signed longterm, it changes the picture for many a current outfield prospect in the system.
-
I'm actually looking at the Twins current 40-man, and there isn't a lot of player movement if you wanted to add a body. Who do you subtract in the grand scheme of things. Gordon? Smeltzer? If Thielbar stunk up the bullpen, easy cut. But he is holding his own. Garlick and Blankenhorn? Chalmers, Colina and Ober - all higher than Wells in the pecking order. During the off-season you do keep a couple of potential clunkers on the 40-man because you may have to jettison someone for a free-agent signing (which the Twins did, or a trade). But, man, the 40-man is tight. Happily ALL the names would be a potential call-up if the need arose. (Otherwise, why have them on the roster, or in the case of Babboo you would be carrying him (like Celestino) for a couple of seasons with no call-up because you think he is THE ONE.
-
Twins 2021 Position Analysis: Designated Hitter
Rosterman replied to Nick Nelson's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I'm hoping that Rooker does make the lineup as the starting leftfielder. If he can produce, he is the designated hitter for the future Twins, who can also play the field at first or the outfield. Sano, of course, is also in the running, and it is nice to have a DH who can play in the field, in this case Sano at 1B or 3B. Throw a revitalized Garver into the mix, as a guy who could be a DH who could also be that backup at 1B or C, and all we really need to hope is that Cruz hits the gates running and doesn't slowdown for the first half of the season. If he does start to tire, it is nice to know that Twins could have a good looksee to their options beyond 2021. -
You don't get quality and a player still under control by giving a team players you really don't want. You have to give them guys you think you might want to keep, but are getting something stronger in place. The Reds can keep their pitcher and buy a shortstop comparable to Polanco. You would have to trade one of the young gun arms, and probably one of the outfield arms in the deal, period, end of discussion. The Twins shant do that. Both their top arms are controllable for up to six seasons. Krill and Lar will push Sano off the roster.
-
Commission the rings now ... Twins sign Andrew Romine
Rosterman replied to MMMordabito's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
I wish Gordon was better setup for this opportunity. We'll see how this all pans out! -
I like what the front is doing. They signed Donaldson to a big contract to hold down third base. I see possibilities in the system when Donaldson moves away from the bag in (hopefully) two years. They signed starting pitchers as a stopgap before prospects move up this season (and subsequent ones). The question remains the need to keep Berrios and for how much. They should've gotten something for Rosario, sadly. Losing him because of arbitration is a somewhat loss, but you do have replacements that need to play in Rooker and Kirilloff. The Twins have also signed temporary emergency stopgaps if need be. Next is Larnach. So this is the year Buxton and Kepler need to shine to stay with the Twins. Celestino is also someone I want to see. The Twins signed a Royce Lewis stopgap, but there is no doubt that it is time for Royce to shine in the minors to break into the lineup this season. The Twins have two young catchers. Plus a couple of prospects in the system. The system is loaded with arms. Sadly they still play like all they need to do is win the division. AT some point they have to pull the big mid-season trade to go all-the-way. But I think the system is quite rich with tradebait names that may or may not pan out. It sure hurt NOT to have a 2020 minor league season. Injuries are always the key to success. The Twins do seem to have depth pretty much everywhere with replaceable parts.
- 64 replies
-
- josh donaldson
- byron buxton
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
Twins Announce Non-Roster Invites
Rosterman replied to Seth Stohs's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Minor league free agents do make a decent salary to play ball as they age, and there is just the chance. You never ever know.- 24 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Odorizzi is a five inning pitcher. But could the Twins live without Dobnak, Smeltzer or Thorpe longterm? Could Thorpe develop into a solid bullpen arm if nothing else? That is the bigger question with him. Looking at the Twins alternatives and that there are still arms of equal strength to "buy" - the Twins basically need someone who can pitch half-the-0season and possibly be tradebait, with hopes that Bala or Duran can come up during the season, or that two of the three I mentioned above are still in the wings in case of an emergency need.
-
Rooker gives us a great alternative if Sano continues to...lumber along. With Kirilloff and Larnach in the mix, not to mention the possibilities of Celestino. outfield is not really an issue. The Twins have some fine prospects. You look at the production of Kepler, Buxton and Sano. They all have some pluses, but also aren't tearing things up. Stat wise, Rosario looked better on paper overall. The Twins have some players to make long-term decisions about, use as tradebait for room for the youngsters, and a possible dynasty in the making from the Falvey/Levine administration.

