So, what exactly was it about his 2016 season that you didn't like? I really don't see a winning record, sub 3.00 ERA, and virtually no HRs allowed to players 3 to 3 1/2 years older than him as negative in any way. 2017 was bad, but I don't think you can honestly look at the rest of his numbers and say it's been bad. If you can, and seriously believe it, your expectations are WAY too high. The only thing I can see that hasn't been where most people would like it, is the strikeouts. But that's a pretty weak negative. There's more to pitching than Ks.