5th best among 1B doesn't really say much...They aren't exactly an athletic bunch. I don't really see much of this roster as being particularly great on the base paths either, so comparing him in that context doesn't do much for me either. I just don't think this team has been a great baserunning team for the last handful of years. The lack of SB attempts reflects that, even with Gardy's reluctance to send guys. If the talent was there, he would have used it. Buxton in particular would be everyone's choice at the top if he would get on base more. Obviously that isn't happening right now, so no I don't want him there right now. All that being said, Mauer at the 2 is a better option than most on this current roster. He isn't my ideal #2 for reasons already stated, but I don't have a better candidate at this time either. The roster simply isn't constructed in a way that provides a viable #1 and #2 hitter. I agree that Mauer is baseball smart and generally has good instincts, I just don't think baserunning is a strength of his though. He's much stronger defensively and at the plate.