I am glad that Gibson is getting his chance. This thread highlights the fact that there will always be conflict between fans who sincerely and passionately believe that the front office is incompetent and fans who sincerely and passionately believe that the front office is competent. It understand that some of the comments about bringing up a position player could be upsetting to members who just want to celebrate the good news. At the moment, I personally would rather not have my celebration interrupted by more complaining about the FO. However, I have read the TD policy MANY times and unless complaining about the FO rises to the level of trolling, and so long as the complainers are respectful, I believe that we need to be tolerant of complaining. I believe that tolerance for the "complaining" of others is very important, because it seems to me that both sides of this debate are sincere. Some of our most intelligent and articulate members appear to sincerely believe that the FO has made many major mistakes that they deserve strong criticism. Often, I disagree with these criticizers and get tired of their posts. But on balance I am glad that they are here. The criticizers keep us all honest by bringing up points that might otherwise be ignored. I would ask only that we all make a renewed effort to be respectful, keeping in mind that we are all fans of the same team.