I agree 100% with my colleague and would add (as has been stated many times) that it's perfectly OK to emphatically criticize Gardy or anyone else, so long as you follow the TD policy as posted at the top of the main forum. The policy even gives helpful examples. For example, it is OK to say that you believe that Gardy's handling of the bullpen is totally incompetent and that you believe that the Twins should fire him tomorrow, preferably giving reasons for your opinion. But it's not OK to call Gardy (or anyone else) names like "idiot", "fat moron", "incompetent parasite" or "G-Slug." The policy is not intended to restrict what you can say. The goal of the policy is to keep the discussion respectful, so that we can have rational discussions instead of flame wars.