Here is my perspective. I don't think gunnar's post is irrelevant to the conversation. In very broad terms this whole incident brings to fore clashing world ideologies, and freedom of speech has become part of that discussion. Charlie Hebdo isn't just publishing satire for satire's sake. They are publishing satire for a very pointed agenda. While the freedom of speech discussion is an entirely different one, there are a lot of questions of responsibility surrounding this incident. I find some of this satire ... reprehensible, quite frankly; but I think they still have right to create it and publish it. And everyone has the choice to ignore it, not support it, support it, read it, buy it, protest it, whatever. And the group being 'challenged' by the content do not have the right to respond in the violent manner they did. I don't think anyone has that right. But at what point does freedom of speech go too far? At what point are those doing the poking at all liable? And why the need to demean, belittle, offend, degrade? Face it, this wasn't satire for humor regardless of any humor any found in it. (And no, an emphatic no, I am not suggesting in any way, shape or form, that any of these victims deserved this, brought this on, should have been censored, or any such thing.) But at what point does this go too far? That said, no matter what group is being 'satired,' even for, to me, an agenda I do not support, no one has the right to take life, to respond so violently, in the name of anything, anyone or any Being. But as we bury ourselves in Paris, Nigeria goes unnoticed. To the broader sense ... ideologies. There is no answer for it. Maybe someday we all will learn how to live side by side no matter what our beliefs and/or disagreements. Maybe for a start we check our anger and our easily offended sensibilities and quit accusing the other and try a little humility and think that maybe, just maybe, no one is 'right' or 'wrong.' That all said ... my above moderator note stands. Please discuss. Try not to get personal with it or take it personally. At the end of the day, instead of holding someone else in disdain for something they said or something you think they meant, and remember that all lives count.