We wouldn't have made the playoffs without his contribution? How do you figure? I mean, technically, everyone who played made a contribution, so in that sense, sure. But his contribution was mostly about stinking up the joint almost the whole season. For as well as he pitched for a month down the stretch, also have to include how he did the rest of the time cause all games count the same during the season. There are plenty of pitchers who could have contributed like he did and we still get in. 71 SP in the AL had 150 more IP, he ranked 60th in FIP and WAR. For the ERA lovers, he ranked 64th. He was 85th in WHIP. He DID manage to get a lot of run support. 90 pitchers in baseball had 140 or more IP, he got the most run support: 6.62. Next highest was 6.21 (and that was the NL). The next highest in the AL was Cole Hamels and 6.13. And he got demoted.