We can't say the team needs bats then immediately say the team should trade Jeffers and/or Larnach, proven bats help you win now. Carrying 3 C is not ideal, but Shelton seems to be managing it OK. Trading Caratini may be the right move, but then the team is looking for a C next year because neither Jeffers nor Caratini will be here and the prospects in the minors are a couple of years away at the earliest.
Detmers and Gore are not going to come cheaply because they still have team control attached to them, neither has a great track record, and I don't feel the team should mortgage the future for "potential", though that is what the future (and the MiLB system) is built on. The team already has potential and team control in Bradley, Rojas, Abel, Matthews, Prielipp and a few others with rising stock in the minors. It remains to be seen how much this group helps down the stretch, but Detmers and Gore are no guarantee to help either, and then the SP logjam begins fresh next spring.