Jump to content
Joe Ryan is on the bump as the Twins try to end the Mets' one-game winning streak! Join our game thread! ×
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

karcherd

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    976

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

News

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospects Ranking

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

Minnesota Twins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by karcherd

  1. karcherd
    How can he be an asset, his command is not there consistently, he has had one good outing. And that was against a team with inexperienced hitters who are more prone to chasing his offspeed offerings just like in AAA. A team i.e. the Phillies with experienced hitters will not chase and force him into the zone and he does not have hit and miss stuff. Why do we get so fascinated with these fringey veterans that have nothing left. Can we raise expectations on this front office to actually bring in players that can contribute and stop with the lottery ticket hopefuls.
  2. karcherd
    You seriously think Keuchel should even be in consideration to be on the post reason roster. We may as well as mail it in if he is on the roster.
  3. karcherd
    Yes platooning as been around for a long time in baseball. The problem is the way the Twins employ the strategy. You can not have a team of platoon players, you need to have stars and everyday players. If you have 4 or 5 positions that you are platooning, the majority of your players are limited by nature and you will be a .500 team. You need to have to 5 or 6 players that you can count on to be everyday players and mix and match the others in based on matchups. We basically have three players that are not considered platoon players, Buxton when healthy, Correa and Polanco. You don't have to sit a left handed hitting player against every left handed pitcher. Only when you are facing the tougher left handers, do they sit. Randy Johnson is the first example that comes to mind, many left hand hitting batters sat against him regardless if they were a starter or not because he was tough on them. But we were sitting lefties against Joey Wentz of the Tigers, if Julien and Wallner can't hit him there are bigger issues.
  4. karcherd
    He wasn't used last time Keuchel got lit up, so I am not sure why they have him on the roster.
  5. karcherd
    Keuchel needs to be DFA'd, he should not be on a major league roster for any role.
  6. karcherd
    Can we stop hoping for washed up journeyman veteran players will help us, Garlick does nothing for this team. Bring up the best player regardless of what side of the plate they hit from. It is not illegal to have left handed hitters in the line up against left handed pitchers.
  7. karcherd
    I agree, but they were playing against a pitcher that should not be considered a tougher pitcher to face. They should be playing a couple of days a week. But if we play lefties 5 days in a row, they will be in there. That is my concern, not all players are equal in ability, so when you sit players who should be regulars you are weakening your team. If you want to use the splits as rigid as the Twins you need to upgrade your bench dramatically and not have role players.. It works for one game but you have to play for the whole season.
  8. karcherd
    Or they could put in their best hitters regardless of how they hit. Not every LH should be sitting just because a LH is pitching. You can't have a team of platoon players for season long success.
  9. karcherd
    Gallo gets on average two hits a week and one is for extra bases. His defense has to be Platinum Glove level to be even considered for a spot on this roster and it is not. If this was any other player not named Buxton or Correa they would have been gone long ago.
  10. karcherd
    They have filled 1B on the fly before, Arraez last year is an example. They played Farmer there in the late innings the other night. Move Julien or Polanco there until Kiriloff is back. There is no excuse to continue keeping Gallo on the roster another day especially for a contending team.
  11. karcherd
    Or could it be there was no interest in him.
  12. karcherd
    The Dodgers picked up players who at least have been in the majors this year and have had some measure of recent success. So what is the difference, Keuchel wasn't even signed to a minor league until June, he had an opt out clause in July and chose not to take it. Why didn't he take the opt out because teams were not calling his agent saying hey come pitch for us. He also has no success for 4 years. Big difference in the caliber of players.
  13. karcherd
    What is this fascination with Keuchel, another washed up veteran pitcher. So he has some good stats at the AAA level. Are we just going to ignore what he has done at the major league level the last three years. He is just another Bundy, Happ, Shoemaker, Archer reclamation project. Championship teams try to improve their roster with proven players not reclamation projects that they hope will do something, especially not in August. The time to try this is in spring training. If there was a LH prospect with his stuff pitching with his numbers this board would be saying that those numbers would not be sustainable with the Twins. But yet because it is a name who has had no success in 4 years, we think he can come up here and help win a pennant for us.
  14. karcherd
    Give Gallo away to the first team that calls, get a bag of balls or send one to get rid of him. The last two games they have pinch hit for him because he can't make contact. Why is he even in the lineup.
  15. karcherd
    The other option in the 10th inning would have been to let Kepler hit and pinch hit Farmer for Wallner. This keeps the defense stronger and keeps Vazuqez on the bench. Both players did not need to be pinch hit for just because a LH was on the mound. Rocco needs to show some flexibility in these situations and not just pinch hit for the sake of pinch hitting. You need to have a quality option available and that is not Vazquez.
  16. karcherd
    Good does not mean elite.
  17. karcherd
    Elite defense, have you been watching his routes to the ball in CF. I know he hasn't played there much, but calling him elite defensively is a bit of hyberbole.
  18. karcherd
    These are all good options, but who are you going to take off the 26 man roster. The front office appears to want to ride with Gallo. So really the only options would be Solano or Castro unless Buxton on the IL. I would be good with any of these players but it can't be at the expense of taking ab's from Kiriloff even against lefties. We probably bullpen help more at this point.
  19. karcherd
    Gallo should be the one to go. Get whatever you can for him or release him. And stop worrying about LH/RH splits, play your best players every day. Not all players are equal in ability and by having so many platoon players they are not always putting out their best lineup.
  20. karcherd
    I would not count on Paddack this year. First this was his second TJ surgery and there is not a lot known about the recovery timeline, they are all different. And remember last Maeda was supposed to back in September and then they shut him down. The Twins are very conservative with injury management, I would be surprised if they have him pitch this year.
  21. karcherd
    Give him consistent playing time and make a determination. You can't make every player a platoon player. Gallo has an OPS in the mid .600 the last two months. So why would you continue giving at bats if you can get the same results from someone who has more of a potential future with the team. We need more regular starters, you are not going win with platooning 6 positions, that implies those players are all equal in ability. And that is not the case.
  22. karcherd
  23. karcherd
    Why would Kiriloff be at risk of losing his roster spot. Who do they have that takes better at bat's. Maybe they should try to give him consistent playing time. Kepler can go up there and flail away and not ever worry about his playing time. The way this team develops the young players is not very good. Stop with the obsession with right/left splits and put your best 9 players which Kiriloff is one of.
  24. karcherd
    Good teams find a way to get their best players in the lineup regardless of position. If the Twins send Julien down, it should signal the end for this decision making trio. This would show they are either too inflexible or stubborn to find solutions to field the best team possible. And Julien has played 3 innings this weekend, he can hit left handed pitchers. Play him until he shows he can't.
  25. karcherd
    They would have to decide to make Kiriloff a full time player and not a platoon player for this plan to work.
×
×
  • Create New...