I will always advocate trading a closer for another position player or starter. The position of closer is way over rated, especially on a team with out much chance of winning a division title or wildcard race for several years. Give me a good fielding, decent hitting SS (Gordon is 3 years away...Polanco is 2 years away), catcher (?), 2B (We've got a good one-Dozier) and CF (Buxton is 2 years away) and then build around them. Several flame throwing RH pitchers (Meyer, Berrios, Stewart) and one good lefty starter (?). Some good fielding OF with decent arms and power- Sano and ?), a power 3B (?...Polanco, but no power), Mauer at 1B complete with his singles and doubles, a good relief corps, which we have at the major league level and at AAA and AA. A DH made up of all the other guys (Little Papi, aka Vargas-?). Closer is the last position to fill.