I was on the Winder to St. Paul bandwagon until considering how well he’s thrown and that he’s 25.
Here’s my slight variation on the piggy back plan, at least as long as Gray, Bundy, Archer, Paddack, Ryan and Ober are healthy.
Rather than tie Winder to a specific pitcher, tie him to a specific day. That has a couple advantages, in my mind. First, it seems likely that he’s going to be on some kind of innings limit. Pitching one game a week gives him essentially 26 games. If he averages 4.5 innings, that’s 119 innings. Second, virtually none of the starters is likely to go over 150 innings, for various reasons. In the past, it’s not been unusual to skip a start for someone. Tieing Winder to a day means that over time he’ll end up piggy backing different pitchers over time. What that does is give each starter that occasional game that is a very light game. One week it’s Archer, the next week it’s Bundy, Ober, etc. As a recovery tool, virtually all (maybe all!) would benefit from an occasional game where they go 45 pitches (three innings) and shower early and this gets them that.
While Winder Wednesday has obvious marketing potential, I go with Saturday. A starter going three, followed by Winder going five nearly gives the bullpen a reset in the middle of what’s nearly always at least a three-game series. No other day gives that. Additionally, there are at least a couple Saturday doubleheaders, right? On those days, you give the regular starter game one (and don’t pull after three) and use Winder in game two.
Plans like this always look good on paper, but never last long term, either because of injuries or ineffectiveness. If one of the other starters is out for either reason, you just switch to a five-man rotation, continuing to manage Winder this way. If a second is out, just slide Winder into what becomes a new five-man rotation.