In fairness, Ryan didn't sign or trade Santana, leaving Smith to do that work. Or, he could have offered him arbitration.....would that have been worth what they got? The Garza trade was the exact trade people here praised Ryan for doing with Span and Revere. I am told I can't judge the Meyer Span trade on the outcome, only what people knew at the time, and that the process matters more. So, ya, they picked the wrong guy, but you can't say it is the process with Ryan, and the outcome with Smith and be fair on how we are judging them. btw, none of this means I think Smith is better or worse than Ryan, all I'm asking for is that when we do compare them, we are fair in how we talk about them..... there is no excuse for the Capps or Hoey trades, none.