I am not debating this year, and having Robinson on the roster means you can cut him or whatever......but having Hunter on the roster means he's on the roster. Another FA? don't give them a no trade clause, sign them for 1 year. Bingo, you have roster flexibility if one of Arcia, Buxton, Rosario, Hicks, Kepler, random FA, Robinson doesn't work (wait, you'd need 2-3 of them not to work). That's the point on the 4th OF next year......he might play regularly for a month or two while Buxon is down, but you want him on the bench full time after that. You should, imo, plan for that player to be on the bench after that, so you should sign a guy based on that expectation. Heck, you might want him cut if Arcia is your 3rd OF next year, and you bring up Buxton.......