He was pretty bad against righties. I don't know anything about the future, but you can look at the past and make predictions....I would be shocked if Rogers is a good MLB SP. As for the catching, I think working with pitchers, understanding umpires, etc....all the non-game stuff, I think they need at least 1 guy that knows how that works. I could be wrong, but that's my thought. Also, neither even has, what 50 ABs in AAA? I am all for "play the young guys" as a strategy, you can do that with a young guy as the starter.