MapleGroveTwinsFan
Verified Member-
Posts
160 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by MapleGroveTwinsFan
-
Then it is time to fold the Twins,, if Bradley, Jenkins, Culpepper, Keashall and Lee (was is still pre-arb) next year, then there really is no reason to a be a major league organization. But you are correct, looking at the 40 there isn't that much and if guys like Matthews, Erod, Gomez, Morris and a couple guys close to the majors don't step it up, things look bleak for the future. I will say people on here didn't want the Twins to really go for it a few years back because 2025/26/27 were the years the Twins should be planning for.
-
So part of the plan is offer both of Larnach and Ober Arb and trade them for prospects? Ober made 6.5 this year and Larnach 6.25, lets say the both get a small bump. So the Twins are going to pay 15 million or so and a back end of the top 30 guy to get a better prospect for a A ball lottery ticket and a better prospect? Picking up Polanco's 10.5 million dollar option and Farmer's 6.25 worked out so well the Twins should try that plan once again, but not even for a top 100 prospect this time? Plus the twins are going to trade Ryan plus a prospect for Michael Busch who is 29 and coming off a year with an OPS+ of 104 and bat him 3rd? The angels will trade for Lewis who will make about 5.7 next year for Ballesteros you have him as a OF/DH when he has never played an inning in the outfield in the majors and has barely ever caught and Rodrguez who each have at least 3 years of control? Going to make Jeffers the highest paid catcher in the game, even though though his first 7 years he has only played more than 100 games twice. Pay Lopez somewhere between 110 and 130 million to pitch from age 31 - 35. (after making 14 starts in two years) Offer Minter less than he is making this year? Everyone of these seem very unlikely to happen or not a great idea if they do.
- 67 replies
-
- victor caratini
- ryan jeffers
- (and 5 more)
-
Royce Lewis debuted at 23, and Rooker at 25, not sure how that compares. Rooker has had one great season, 1 season with a WAR of 2 and one with 1.8, and the rest below replacement and will be 32 in two months. Lewis been a league average player at best minus a month or so back in 2023. Not sure these two guys are making the case you think you are. Sure if Buxton puts up a 5 WAR season, Keashall, Jenkins, Lee, Erod, Culpepper and Clemens put up WARs between 2 - 4 then trying a 27 year old rookie isn't a terrible idea, if those things don't happen and they try out a 27 year old and he fails, well it will be another year of missing the playoffs. Sabato should be depth for next year and if somebody gets hurt they should give him a shot.
-
You could give examples because they do exist, but for every example there are 100 (probably more) to counter them. I don't blame Shelton for Jackson, that IMO lays directly at the feet of the front office.
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Sabato has played 2B 1 game for 6 innings in his whole college and minor league career and has only DH'd 21 times (all this year) .
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Because they have more skills and projectablity? GG, Erod, Jenkins Culpepper all got to AAA years before Sabato (on top of his struggles at an older age in the low minors, .692 OPS in 412 PA in A, .844 in 445 PA in A, .749 in 931 PA in AA, .833 in 727 in AAA) How many minor league players age 26 or older have been tearing up AAA and people on this site claimed was going to be the next Dozier or solution to a Twins issue? Dozier was a unicorn and still only had 3 years with an OPS+ above 104 and career was over at age 33. Older guys in the minors should only be thought of depth and when given a chance and do well ride them and when they start struggling move on.
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Clement has an OPS of .669 (OPS+83) and has a career OPS of .671 (OPS+83) (and weird when the other Jays aren't hitting as expected they are below .500) It worked last year when Kirk (2.3 WAR), Vlad(4.6 WAR), Bichette (3.4 WAR), Varsho (2.7 WR), Springer (4.8 WAR), Straw (2.8 WAR), Scheider (1.3), Barger (1.2). Magnum has an OPS of .703 (OPS+91), career OPS of .700 (OPS+93), and likely was a place holder until Valdez was ready, and played more because of Cruz injury, and has been slightly better than average player (but not batter) Clemens first time in his career he has an OPS+ of 114, and it took 5 years and 4 teams, lets see if he continue and it play similar to Clement, if he is one of the top players on the team .500 is good goal for the team.
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
It isn't that you should stop drafting college kids (Culpepper and Lackey for example) it is that if this college kids take 4 or 5 years to actually start producing in the minors (not pitchers) an injuries weren't the cause they shouldn't be counted on for anything more than part time/utility/back up type players because the odds are so overwhelming bad that will become anything more than that is so very, very low. Teams absoletly need players like this to fill the back end of the roster because they are cheap, usually have options or are expendable, it is this type of players that shouldn't be blocking the younger prospects that have better odds of being more than that. (admittedly still not great odds)
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
In case anybody was wondering Sabota is 1 day older than Lewis, so expecting him to come up and better or even the same as Lewis is quite the optimism. If people are fine with moving on from Lewis (I am), Sabato shouldn't be the guy you are hoping replaces him.
- 71 replies
-
- luke keaschall
- brooks lee
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
The 5 Biggest What-Ifs for the 2026 Twins
MapleGroveTwinsFan replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
What if Wallner wasn't terrible, what if Lewis was better, what Erod started the season with the Twins, What if, what if, what if. Waste of time we seen what happened.- 19 replies
-
- byron buxton
- pablo lopez
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
When the team was good and had talent he was not good (and that is being kind), I do give him credit he did get better over time but by then the talent and payroll were less. I watch more games on the other teams channel than the Twins, and I can't even count the times the other announcers would question what the Twins were doing and/or just laugh and explain why it was such a bad decision. We will know what the rest of the league thinks of him by how many more chances he gets to manage.
- 57 replies
-
- taylor rogers
- emmanuel rodriguez
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
You should only extend the young guys, there are exceptions, (maybe a guy like Prilelipp who debuted at 25 because of a injury (think DeGrom), Catchers are a little different as well, they should have tried to extend Jeffers in the 24 season, but guys like Ober/Ryan/Matthews should be used/abused (I don't mean in a bad way, just shouldn't be protected like a younger guy (see Messick) and traded off and hopefully you hit on a Bieber type every know and then.
- 57 replies
-
- vahn lackey
- enrique jimenez
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
💯in agreement again, That is why only having guys that are ready for the majors at 24, 25, 26 hurt the twins even more (offensive/defensive players, Starting pitchers are a little different, because teams are likely to trade for a pitchers in his mid/late 20's with a year or more of control). Which of course they Twins haven't traded (Ryan and Ober for example) When you have young guys (23 or younger, 22 or younger even better) they can extend them at less that market rates (like the Twins did with Kepler, Sano, Polanco), IMO they should try offering Keashall an extension this year, and Culpepper and maybe Jenkins next year, and of course Lackey if he forces his way up.
- 57 replies
-
- vahn lackey
- enrique jimenez
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
💯in agreement with you, (They also cycle pretty quickly though guys they see aren't a long term fixture to the team, which the Twins haven't done with anybody, they just keep crossing their fingers they will get better)
- 57 replies
-
- vahn lackey
- enrique jimenez
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
Likely had something to do with Bundy and Archer starting a third of the games(54) for the Twins, No?
- 57 replies
-
- vahn lackey
- enrique jimenez
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
I am not saying this because I think Lackey should be brought up right away (he will still be 21 until July 7th next year) But the saying you only have them for 5 years, is kind of a defeatist attitude, because nothing is stopping the team the extending them (lots of teams do that), and generally is only a good idea to do with guys that are brought up on the younger side, (there are older guys that it can be done with as well, but generally teams don't do that, maybe has to do with the player knowing they will likely only get one big pay day and it is best to get that around 30 and not 33 (Prime example is Pablo debuted at 22 and Ryan debuted at 25, both will be free agents at age 31, Pablo will have made 80 million and Ryan around 22)
- 57 replies
-
- vahn lackey
- enrique jimenez
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
Currently 91 major league pitchers have a WAR higher than Ober's 1.8, Ober isn't the problem with the Twins team it is the FO roster construction that is the problem. It isn't a Ober problem, or really any individual on the team or manager for that matter, the problem soley lays at the feet of the Front Office and above. The Twins are loaded with league average players (and injury prone) and the inability to develop or bring in players above league average to supplement this is the problem. Continuing to bring them them back and/or bringing in more of them and hoping for better results have given us the last half of a decade. The idea of bringing back Larnach, Lewis, Bell, Ober, Kremer and to a lesser extent Jeffers like so many on here said isn't likely to change the outcome of 27, but maybe next year will be different than the last 3 years of trying it.
-
Couldn't one argue he put the team in position to draft those guys that highly?
- 20 replies
-
- brooks lee
- connor prielipp
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
I thought how could one of the top candidates for Twins minor league pitcher be a guy that has pitched less than 60 innings. The I ran though the stats from the minor league teams, and thought the Twins minor league pitching is not good at least stats wise.
- 5 replies
-
- adrian bohorquez
- graham brown
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Has he? He has one game with more than 5 1/3 innings out of 7 (really good 7 innings 1 run), two with 4 innings and at least 4 earned runs, Three decent starts with 5 innings (1,2,1 runs) and a 5 1/3 with 4. If you aren't willing to give Matthews a shot over him, when are you ever going to give a prospect a shot?
-
Based on your criteria Bradly 16/28 - 57% Ryan 13/24 - 54% Matthews 10/21 - 48% Ober 10/22 - 47 Prilipp 7/19 - 37% Kremer 4/7 - 57% Matthew only has one start that falls into your criteria that isn't considered a QS, Ryan and Bradley have multiple games that fit your criteria but fall short of a QS. I agree when Matthews hasn't been good, he has been mostly real bad. IMO that is enough to give him a spot in the starting rotation next year, unless of course they go out and get somebody better in a trade or FA, but that doesn't mean I also wouldn't be keeping him on a short lease.
-
If the Twins are playing Lopez 18 million, Ryan 10 or whatever he gets, Ober more than his 5.2 he made this year, and Kremer around 5 or whatever he gets, who do you think the Twins will give the starting pitchers chances to and how long of lease do they get? I am all for having as many arms as possible, but the top guys better be real good or real inexpensive

