Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

MapleGroveTwinsFan

Verified Member
  • Posts

    160
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by MapleGroveTwinsFan

  1. Sometimes I wonder how much research you put into things? "But the organization also has plenty of evidence for why patience can be valuable. As explored earlier this year, the Twins had opportunities to make long-term commitments to players such as Royce Lewis, Jose Miranda and Matt Wallner when their perceived values were significantly higher" They already had Lewis locked up though his age 29 season and was coming off majors injuries, extending somebody in that situation is not what teams in the majors do. Wallner they have/had locked until 31 already, I believe the same with Miranda. The same reason for Ryan and Ober, the reason for extending them to to keep them during their prime, not on the other side of 30. That group of players are nothing like Keaschall, Jenkins, Erod, and Culpepper, I think Keaschall, Jenkins and Culpepper are obvious guys they should be talking to about this, Erod, probably still a year away. Bradley is the good question, I believe he is locked up though age 28, so probably a guy they should as well, but might another year like they did with Lopez (somebody you failed to mention in the article) Prielipp is in the same boat as Ober and Ryan were already locked up though his prime years, but if the Twins think he is on the Jacob deGrom path you have to consider it, but you have believe his career is on the deGrom/Skubal path to do that. Teams extend guys that made their major league debut at 19.20.21 and 22, maybe a rare occasion 23, but not later than because if the debut after that they already have them though their prime years. Which explains, the Polanco, Sano, Kepler, Buxton, and Lopez and not the Lewis, Julien, Wallner, Larnach, Ryan and Ober's of the world. Seems like a detail that should be in the article, not talking about Wallner.
  2. I would assume there are a team or three out there that Joe Ryan would fit nicely in their rotation, have a better chance at extending him then the Twins and give up something pretty decent. Then the Twins could use that money and some of the money they have talked about spending, and sign a pitcher to a 2 or 3 year contract. That way they get some prospects, another starter locked up for the next couple of years when the young guys hopefully have gotten better. Then they continue to spend money on holes. It seems very like a horrible plan to go into next year with your two "best" starters FA at the end of the year and think you can trade them at the deadline, what if they are actually competing for a playoff spot, I mean really competing,, what if they get hurt again, or just aren't that good, they will have pissed away two of the best trade assets they have had in years. Maybe Lopez would take a two year extension jut to keep him here, Ryan won't nor should he. You can do two things at once, trade Ryan and sign somebody to replace him. I think the term for that is asset management,? weird concept walking and chewing gum at the same time, crazy. Maybea Bieber, Rogers, Bubic or Buehler type would sign a two or three contract,
  3. So the Twins are going to sign him to a contract of 2 to 3 years between 30 - 50 million at the minimum and people think this is a good way for the Twins to spend money? At 15 million a year he becomes the 5th highest paid closer in the game (the 4 above play for the Houston, Dodgers, Mets and Braves, I ask again is this a good way for the Twins to spend money? Seems like the type of player you sign when you haven't missed the playoffs the last three years, and Jenkins, Culpepper and others have proven something, not still trying to prove themselves. Also seems like a player people will be pissed he is making so much for a .500 club and demanding him to be traded for prospects.
  4. So basically run the same team out there for the 4th year, third time wasn't a charm but the 4th time might be? Smart mid to small market teams don't extend pitchers on the wrong side of 30 they trade them, unless of course it is a year or two at the most, and Kremer is the only one that might take that. I would agree there isn't many places to spend money on the offensive side of the equation, but there is a path on the pitching side after they do the right thing and trade Ryan. They missed a huge opportunity to help reload the minors by not trading Jeffers, Ryan, Lopez and one of Wallner or Larnach before last year.
  5. Crazy talk, Morrisette is a year older than Lee and has never played in the majors, Ross is 6 months younger has 21 plate appearances in the majors and they might push Lee off a position? You don't think if Lee was in the minors he would be putting up better numbers than either of them two. He hit more homers in the majors than either of those two did in the minors. Both of those two guys future are utility/bench guys. 🫣
  6. The is so much bipolar on this site it is crazy. Lee had a solid year, maybe better. Has improved offensively by around 20% each year he has been in the majors (will turn 26 before the season). Played in 156 games, a number hardly any Twins have been able to do for a while. Drove in 13 less runs than Bell batting second, or lower than 5th all year. He is exactly what we should be hoping for the twins prospects. Continue to get better entering his prime years, sure it would have been nice for him to hit the ground running be a plus player but that is hard to do and somewhat rare. He is entering his prime and has established himself as a full time player, compare that to the Miranda, Julien, Larnach, Martin, Wallner, Keirsay, Fedko, Roden's of the world who at his age were still in the minors or struggling entering their primes. If one or two of those guys had the same trajectory as Lee this team wouldn't be in the position they are in. Now the Hope is Culpepper, Jenkins, Houston, Erod, Lackey have similar paths and the Twins actually are building a future. As for metrics, after it has happened (game, week, month, season) they are pretty useless, the numbers are the numbers, how they got to them is irrelevant. Arguing one player is better than another player based on metrics because somebody was lucky or unlucky or won't be able to repeat something is a fools errand and ridiculous. But they absolutely should be looked at and used for predictability, trends and how the team should move forward. I also think that a 26 year old entering his 4th major league season where he has consistently gotten should be looked at a little different than an older established player, or a young (mid to late 20's) guy with little to no experience in the majors.
  7. Oh, I can agree that 26 year old Roden put up better numbers than 21 year old Jenkins and 23 year old Erod. Roden and Erod should have been given more of a chance this year, but the Twins thought running 27 year old Martin, and 28 and 29 year old Wallner and Larnach who can't hit lefties were a better idea. The Twins screwed up not seeing what the had with Erod at the beginning of the year and now he is out of options and must be on the roster, traded or let go. Roden has 2 options left, so pretty much he is going to take a back seat to Jenkins and Roden, unless of course he becomes a first basemen, which in that case he is still likely to go back to the minors. I think the Twins have proven playing older players at the expense of young guys getting experience is the quick way to spend multiple years struggling to play even .500 baseball. Jenkins has a career OPS of .895 in the minors (between the age of 18 and 21), Roden has an OPS of .870 in the minors (between the age of 22 and 26), no team in the majors would have Roden be anything more than a depth for Jenkins.
  8. How can this be true? What Jenkins was able to do in 93 plate appearances at age 21 (.293/.393/.686), compared to what Roden did in his first 153 plate appearances at age 25 (.261/.294/.556)? I am not saying Roden doesn't have a chance for a good career, but nobody compares these two players and says Roden is going to be the better player.
  9. Keaschall played in 152 games, Larnach 122, both had a OPS+ of 120, both bad defensively, Keaschall 20 SB, Larnach 2. Keaschall Spilts - OPS vs RHP .800, vs LHP .742 Larnach splits - OPS vs RHP .819, vs LHP .572 I think the games played, stolen bases, and the splits above are more than enough to justify a higher grade, don't you think? Larnach will be a great platoon player for some team (the Twins don't really have that position available right now) and Keaschall is an everyday player (albeit without a real position as of now, but teams always find a way for a guy like him on the field) Edit, that was without even mentioning their age and cost.
  10. I would say the grades are fairly close but high for everybody. Jeffers (who wasn't great defensively) played in one less game than Buxton with basically the same OPS+ and gets an A- and Buxton a B? I think everybody should be dropped down 1 grade at least and it would be better grades. If Jeffers is an A-, what kind of grade would you give to catchers with better WAR, similar OPS+ and played in 40 to 50 more games(Gabriel Moreno,Drake Baldwin,Liam Hicks)? To be honest there really are only 4 guys that deserve a C+ or higher (keashall, Clemens Buxton, and Jeffers), everybody that was more than decent with the bat wasn't any good on defensive (Bell, Larnach), Lee was slightly better than average hitter, and decent at 3B and the rest of the hitter had moments but were below or well below average hitters. There were a few that didn't have enough at bats to be given a fair grade at the major league level, except Outman and Wallner both deserve F's.
  11. The Root cause of this season, is the same as the last few, Hoping the core guys stay healthy, hoping your younger/older (Larnach/Wallner/Lewis/Martin/Jeffers/Roden/Kriedler/Gray) guys become more than league average, and terrible defense. The injured guys got injured, younger/older guys you could say got better, but not by much, defensive was terrible until the moved guys around and it become adequate? They need to get rid of any of the guys that have been around for the last three years if possible and they ones they can't expect less from them and move them down the pecking order. If they can't trade Ryan, then they need to think of him as their 4th starter, Go get somebody to pitch after (or before) Bradley, and before Prielipp, that way they aren't relying on a guy that has proven to be somebody to not rely on. If they can't trade Buxton (and I think they can't or won't) then be honest with him and tell him, because you can't stay healthy we need 4 legit starting Outfielders and we need to play them, so they will be days you aren't playing, not to keep you healthy but to make sure we have guys ready to go when you aren't healthy.
  12. Then the Twins should upgrade at 3B, move Lee to 2B or Utility, Move Erod or Keschall to 1B, and Make Clemens another utility guy, That way you have a bench of guys that should play, and some defensive flexibility. My opinion on what should be done is based on next year not a organizational approach.
  13. The Twins lost 4 or more games in a calendar week 7 times (one of them was 5), so even if the week they lost 5, they won all those games (against the Royals and Brewers) they would likely be 1.5 out with three to play of course they would be 4th in the wild card standings not 7th, with the White Sox playing KC today and the Rockies this weekend and Cleveland playing KC this weekend it is very unlikely one hot week got them in the playoffs, still in the hunt, but a hot week would have meant not losing any games that week.
  14. Probably best to do it for the other teams as well, it won't make you feel as bad, because this happens to all teams, and to the benefit of the Twins multiple times.
  15. Plus he has two options to get healthy and better, might be a good idea to start him in AAA as a starter and see how that goes, of course if he is healthy and lights out in spring training there is a spot in the bullpen for a guy like that.
  16. I want nothing to do with 30 year old Torres and his declining power, barely above league average bat, and lack of stolen bases. Jazz is interesting, but I assume a huge cost, and that means Lee, Culpepper or Houston ends up a utility guy, or the plan is to play him in CF when Buxton gets hurt, plus it means Clemens to 1B, and Keashall to DH and platoon OF - Not horrible. Arraez is pretty limited to 2B, 1B or not a huge fan of that. Lowe pretty limited to 2B and hasn't really played much at 1B or DH. McNeil has been a below average hitter for 4 of the last 6 years (2022 was pretty awesome, without much power or speed, bad combo in the current baseball world and turns 35 in April. (so this is probably what the Twins will do if available) All except Torres bat left handed, all but Jazz don't run and are on the wrong side of 30 for a multiple year contract. Only Jazz has any real time at 3B and that is a stretch (74 career games, albeit 24 and 25). None play SS so if there is an injury or Culpepper needs to go down, they are NOT sliding over.
  17. I didn't see really see many people saying Culpepper was going to debut much earlier than he actually did. Maybe the Twins FO did, since there solution this year was Kriedler, Gray and Lee at short stop, but that says more about the Twins FO than anything.
  18. Ben Ross and/or Ryan Kreidler could be brought back for cheap (Arb 1) and be the 13th man off the bench to fill in short term, and Kreidler would be easy to DFA if he is no longer needed. And neither of these guys should be playing much if everybody is healthy. Either one could be made a spot start at 3B, SS, 2B. There is no reason for a team in the Twins position to spend money for a back up infielder, that is what low cost older/cheaper players are for. And if the Twins around the deadline are looking like a legit playoff contender and those guys haven't been great, then go out and get a vet FA to be at the deadline. The Twins should only be spending money on guys that are an upgrade over the current starters and don't block your more promising prospects or to replace soon to be free agents, For example if they sign or trade for an outfielder they better being moving one of the prospects to 1B, if they trade Lopez and/or Ryan, get the prospects and sign a pitcher to replace them. And don't keep Ober and/or Kremer and start them and push Prielipp and/Matthews to the pen, do it the other way around, and the young guys aren't holding their own, switch them around. Build a good roster and supplement with Salary, not the other way around.
  19. Not sure a 25 year (he will be March 13) old that hasn't played above AA is a prospect, doesn't mean he can't make the majors and contribute in one fashion or another.
  20. This isn't a defense of Buxton, because his injuries suck and the timing is worse. Since 2021 Buxton has played in 559 games with 2321 at bats and a WAR of 21.4, Jeffers has played in 579 games with 2154 at bats and a WAR of 10.7. Jeffers OPS in September .537, Only played in 8 games in 25, .463 OPS in 24. .943 OPS in 23, only played in 7 games after July 15th in 2022. Jeffers OPS in August .740 (SLG .393), in 2025 .747(SLG .389), In 24 OPS .926 (SLG .593), .IN 23 876 (SLG .538), 22 didn't play. An people are done with Buxton, but want to lock up Jeffers? Doesn't make sense to me. (I get that Jeffers is a catcher, part time catcher really)
  21. They basically drew 2.2 to 3 million between from 2005 until 2019, minus 2016 (1.9) when they won 59 games, Covid happened and since 2000, they have finished 5,3,1 (1.9),4(1.9),4, (3rd or 4th) and it is the fans fault? Maybe the worst post I have seen on this site, and there have been some bad ones.
  22. Spending money next year is short sited since there is very little to spend on. If would be foolish to spend money on the outfield, play the young guys (Jenkins, Erod, Keashall) and Buxton. 3B would be OK if they planned on moving Lee to second, but who? Short stop would be foolish, Maybe 2nd if they plan on Keashall/Clemens at first, First, nobody there really worth it. That leaves catcher (really only Jeffers) and pitching. As for payroll I more worried about what they spend in 28 after Lopez and Ryan's current contracts end. If they want to show the fans something, lock up Jenkins, Culpepper, Bradley, Keashall to longer term contracts. Figure out who between Lopez and Ryan brings back the most trade and trade them, sign King and Bieber,
  23. Lopez turns 31 at the start of next year and will be a FA going into his age 32 season, what agent/player is going to say yea a 2 or 3 year extension is a good idea, unless it is a huge over pay like (3/80 or more), because I would think (unless things drastically change with a new CBA) he would be looking at a 5 year deal in excessive if 110 or more. And if he would take a 2 or 3 year extension we should really worry about his health.
  24. Doesn't boggle my mind, when you see comments of giving Wallner another chance, bring Larnach back, Bring Lewis, Ober, and all the rest of the league average players back and give it another go. If they bring him back at 10 or even a reduced salary, it is proof IMO that Zoll is trying to get fired but knows the Twins ownership is too stupid to do. After the last few seasons bringing back a league average DH makes no sense, because if they are good next year and competing they can just go out a trade for him or somebody like him, having him take away at bats from young players at the beginning of the season is a word I am allowed to use on this site.
×
×
  • Create New...