I think the point being made here is that not rebuilding has not worked. Each of the teams in the AL Central cannot be perennial greats because they don't have the finances to sustain it, so they have to ebb and flow and pool their talent for competitive windows separated by lean years. The Twins have certainly had lean years, arguably interrupted by competitive windows, but not obviously because of Falvey's strategy, but just because baseball is weird and sometimes you get lucky. The thing about the trade deadline deals that irked me is there I couldn't identify the year the team planned to rebound. With so many near-ready pitchers and AAAA outfielders in the mix, it would seem to be 2026, but then you can't field a competitive team with a trash heap bullpen, can you?
And folks are right that Falvey has never attempted a rebuild, but the team has never been in this situation. The writing was on the wall two years ago when the payroll was "rightsized". The Pohlads had already blown their wad, realized two years later than everyone else that the commercial real estate bubble had happened, and needed to set the team on an unprecedented trajectory. The pity is that the rebuild didn't start sooner. But it certainly needs to continue now. Unless ownership can let the cash flow, this team needs to ebb.