While you certainly may be right on the career length and success, the issue is also that we were even put in this situation with CF to begin with, yet again. Buxton had shown nothing yet to lead us to believe he was going to be ready to play full time CF in the majors to start this season, yet we put ourselves in a situation where if/when he failed, our backup options were once again an infielder and Mastroianni. Obviously now we can see that Hicks hasn't been playing well either, but the planning was poor, after making the same mistake previously. It was less a bash on the Hicks for Murphy swap and more a bash on the poor planning that surrounded it. I'm not too happy that Murphy was also supposed to be our grand solution at catcher, but thats a whole different discussion. Certainly too early to pick a winner and loser of that trade, but it hasn't exactly worked as either team planned.