He was helped - greatly - by diaz expanding the strike zone. Don't think he would have gotten shelled, but it would've been a different game without all of those outside strikes.
I would be pleased with any of those guys, depending on the cost of course. This is a sleeper pick, but Reyes Moronta has closer stuff can could be available.
I was hoping someone would write up the analysis - thanks Cody. I question whether the value of the position - catcher - has increased in the Moneyball era; whether more catchers will be elected versus earlier eras.