If these pitchers could really pitch in a MLB pen for the next several years in any meaningful way, the Twins probably wouldn't be DFA'ing them, right? I'm sure the Phillies already have similar guys in their own system that require evaluation (I see they just called up lefty reliever Hoby Milner, a Rule 5 pick last winter that Cleveland returned). I didn't see that MLBTR chat, but even if the Phillies eventually do settle for a 30th ranked prospect for Neshek, they'd be fools to accept that a month in advance of the trade deadline. Neshek was the #2 RP on MLBTR's Top 50 trade candidates list, and #6 overall. The other two top relievers (Robertson and Hand) both have team control beyond 2017, so who knows if their teams will even find common ground with a buyer before the deadline. It's highly unlikely the Phillies will have to settle for less than a 30th ranked prospect, and such a prospect isn't too much to gamble that Neshek will stay healthy for a month and something a little bit better might come along. Also, the Phillies have top waiver priority right now. They have first dibs on any player the Twins put on waivers, for free! (Well, the waiver fee.) They'd be stupid to give up an asset for a waiver candidate except as a last resort (i.e. right before the deadline). They also passed on Haley in the Rule 5 draft last winter. (Plus, Haley is allegedly hurt.) If you want to propose trading junk for Neshek in a month, you may have a case depending on the market, but right now, it's pure fantasy.