The phrase “pitching pipeline” has been a phrase uttered frequently on Twins Daily. A search reveals that the first mention of that exact phrase occurred in 2015, and the term was lighted used through 2021 when we notably had the first article that mentioned it, Seth Stohs’ Building a Pitching Pipeline. The article makes the classic comparison to what Cleveland had going in their starting rotation – filling it with the likes of Corey Kluber, Mike Clevinger, Shane Bieber, Aaron Cavle, and others. Since then, the phrase has been used a total of 850 times as the discourse has ramped up – whether it exists, how strong it is, and how it has lived up to the various expectations we have given it.
I’ve split my plans on this into three parts – the first two going over a smatterings of opinions since the debate began in 2021, the last part going covering my opinions on the matter with analysis of the many pitching prospects that have been through this organization since the “Falvine” regime took over in 2017. Let’s try to understand the arguments that have been offered by taking a look at a variety of articles and comments on the matter, and I'll provide some commentary.
March 2021, Nick Nelson’s Starting Pitcher Analysis
"After four years of assembling the infrastructure and creating a culture of fearless development," wrote Dan Hayes at The Athletic recently, "the Twins front office feels as if its pitching pipeline is finally ready to churn out impressive arms at a more consistent rate." The Twins' top three pitching prospects – Jhoan Duran, Jordan Balazovic, Matt Canterino – are verging on big-league ready.
FYI, at the time of this writing, Balzovic and Canterino hadn’t yet pitched in AA.
June 2021
chpettit19: I firmly believe we'd be starting to see the "pitching pipeline" (not that they'd all come up and be great, but we'd have a better read on if there's real MLB arms in the system) at this point if 2020 had been a normal year. They went into that season, I believe, looking to make it through that season with a mix of veterans doing their thing and rookies getting test runs as injury replacements. Then they planned to be able to hand a spot or 2 in the rotation and pen to youngsters in 2021. Instead they got nothing from rookies last year because the world shut down.
Seansy: I think Falvey has delivered the pipeline of pitching talent but it's just been delayed due to COVID cancelling the minors season last year and all of the injuries now in the following year. Canterino, Enlow, Sands, Ober, Winder, Duran, etc. are all guys they have acquired and developed since taking over… I definitely think Falvey has held up his end of the pipeline even if we're only just barely starting to see the fruits of those labors.
This was an opinion shared by several users, as it was reasonable to suggest the 2020 season altered the timeline. But some began to see it as an excuse:
USAFChief: Did 2020 only happen to Twins minor leaguers?
June-July 2021, Tom Froemming’s On the Minnesota Twins Front Office, Faith and Being Fickle
The overall team success has been there (well, prior to this season) but this front office has not delivered a pitching pipeline nor impact pitching through free agency. About a month ago, Aaron Gleeman of The Athletic took a look back at every Falvey-Levine era free agent signing. It wasn’t inspiring. Their record in trades isn’t looking so great, either.
Another article shared that of July 1st 2021, the Twins pitching staff was 29th in WAR.
August 2021: Matthew Taylor’s 5 Free Agent Options for the Minnesota Twins to Replace José Berríos
Dman: They have about 10 guys that they have drafted or traded for that have a chance to be mid rotation starter types (i.e. throw hard enough, Have above average secondary's, Have had minor league success). If they can't get that pitching to work at the MLB level time to find guys with a better idea how to accomplish that goal. Once they have two or three solid young pitchers they should be set for another 3 to 4 year window and if they keep the pitching pipeline going maybe sustainable good to great seasons. If it doesn't the whole thing falls apart.
February 2022, Jamie Cameron’s The Michael Pineda Conundrum
The Twins have essentially been Cleveland’s opposite organization in recent seasons, struggling to create any meaningful starting pitching pipeline to the majors. This may be on the verge of changing with the Falvey led front office, with Jhoan Duran beginning to dominate at AAA and several other standout options working their way through MiLB.
After a surprisingly poor 2021 campaign left the Twins in last place, questions began to rise about the pitching understandly after the likes of JA Happ, Matt Shoemaker, Randy Dobnak, and Griffin Jax started games and had ERAs over 6.00.
February 2022, Ted Schwerzler’s Twins Trading Offers Exciting Opportunity
Looking at the prospect rankings and, more importantly, the organizational location for Minnesota, it’s clear they need external help. The Twins farm system shows up consistently at the bottom of the teens, and outside of Jordan Balazovic, there isn’t an arm on the farm that’s a top 100 talent and ready to immediately contribute. An explanation for much of the feelings regarding the Twins system relates to the missed time the past few seasons.
Quite a shift in tone from the 2021 preseason article. Different authors, of course, and some key injuries happened in 2021.
mikelink45: Are we all over-rating the minor league arms? Reading TD and following the threads it seems like we have lots of good arms, but stepping outside our community it seems a little sparse.
bean5302: (In response to Balazovic being the only top 100 prospect pitcher) Winder and Balazovic are both potential mid-rotation guys, maybe even higher than that.
March 2022, Nash Walker’s Playoff Expansion Leaves No Excuses for Twins Front Office
The belief that the Twins, coming off a horrifically disappointing 73-win season *can’t* improve enough to win is giving too much slack to this front office. Ownership hired them to build a sustainable winner, a team that would compete every year. I understand there's a pitching pipeline coming.
cHawk: I’ve said this before and I still stand by it, the # of games the Twins win in 2022 will depend on how much the pipeline produces. If it does produce, I think the Twins could have a fighting chance in 2022. But this is the year which that needs to start happening, if there is baseball this year. If it doesn’t then it’s a failure.
DocBauer: Regarding sustainability, that doesn't mean, and has never meant, the Twins would be in contention EVERY season. NOBODY can guarantee that EVERY season. It's about being a good, solid team with a chance to win and be relevant MOST years. (Same with any sport) … But 3 of 5 years, to me, is a mark of sustainability, even with unexpected disaster in 2021.
For the record, the Twins won 78 games and have been to the playoffs in one of three seasons since the expansion and are not on track to do so in a fourth.
April 2022, Nick Nelson’s Twins 2022 Position Analysis: Starting Pitcher
There's a lot of talent in this pipeline. It started coming to fruition a year ago, when Bailey Ober emerged as the team's steadiest starter and Joe Ryan arrived late with an eye-opening first impression. The Twins will be looking for more of where that came from this year, with a bevy of their top prospects in the high minors and at an age (23-25) where players tend to enter the big-league ranks.
THE BAD - I read the words now and they haunt me. Like corrosive acid, they eat away at my very soul. "If the Twins have ever fielded a better and deeper rotation than the one they're set to line up this year, I can't remember it," I wrote when introducing last year's starting pitching analysis. "From top to bottom (and beyond) this unit looks stacked."
I must give credit to Nick, he acknolwedged how off his 2021 starting pitcher analysis was.
Injuries and ill-fated signings ravaged the club's depth in 2021 and left the Twins scrambling for answers. It was understandable as a one-year blip. Another season of dreadful pitching performance will not be nearly as tolerable, and would leave Derek Falvey and Thad Levine open to all the criticism they'll receive. Their defiantly minimalist approach to the offseason pitching market will only be excusable if their methodically developed pitching pipeline pays off, and fast.
MikeSixel: This is the year their beliefs in not signing top FA pitchers and their ability to develop them has to pay off. Or I'd fire them. They've had long enough to draft and develop pitching..... And we're still waiting.
Mike8791: Falvine in 5+ years has not even been able to develop one reliever, no less a starter.
In contrast, here is an April 2022 minor league update:
Wabene: There are some arms in the Saint's bullpen. Let's move quick the big league pen is doing us no favors. Overall you gotta like the pitching SWR, Raya, Hajjar, c'mon now we aren't even talking about Canterino, Varland and Enlow yet. And yet there are more.
Seth Stohs: The pitching pipeline is strong. No doubt about it.
July 2022: Various Game Threads
USAFChief: I sure don't read much about the vaunted pitching pipeline(TM) anymore.
Vanimal46: It’s been very disappointing with the lack of progression in the pitching pipeline. During the preseason, TD had 10 pitchers in the top 20 list. Chase Petty traded for Sonny Gray, so 9 remain. Ryan, Duran, and Winder are the ones contributing and the rest are struggling or injured. Balazovic in particular has been an utter disaster this year.
Bunsen82: Isn’t the goal to have a hitting and pitching pipeline? Compared to 4 years ago we have so much more pitching depth than we did back then. We will have a lot of pitching options for next year. Obviously the bullpen will need help.
Negativity was the common attitude around the idea, as you’d expect in the midst of a second straight losing season, but there were some stragglers that had hope.
Danchat: And the pitching pipeline... we've had a few breakthroughs, but still not close enough to what Cleveland's (like we expected). Outside of Winder, we don't have any prospects on the near horizon that will be able to help this year.
I have news for you, past me. Winder ain’t it!
August: The Tyler Mahle trade
Dman: We needed another starter for this year and next year. Let's hope a pitching pipeline develops in our lifetime and we don't have to make trades like this.
Wabene: Cleveland's vaunted pitching pipeline the Twins are trying to emulate was largely constructed through trades.
Gotta disagree big-time with Wabene, Cleveland wasn’t making trades like moving 3 prospects for 1.5 years of control of a mid-rotation starter.
August 2022: Cody Christie’s “3 Reasons the Twins Farm System Ranking Continues to Drop”
Linus: The vaunted pitching pipeline is turning out to be a garden hose.
KirbyDome89: Am I concerned about the continued inability to develop pitching? Absolutely.
LastOnePicked: 2022 was supposed to be the make-or-break year for this FO's ability to deliver on the pipeline. It hasn't happened, and there are no promising arms on the horizon. Time to move on.
Nicksaviking: So we were expecting everyone to pop up and be Atlanta circa ‘95? You’re being unreasonable with the expectations of inexperienced pitchers.
USAFChief: I'm not sure I was ever the one on the unreasonable side of expectations. But I hope I'm proven wrong, and we get some reliably above average pitching next year beyond Duran.
With the hindsight of 2023, I can tell Chief that we did get more “reliably above average” pitching, but it came from veteran additions / better play from the likes of Pablo Lopez, Brock Stewart, and Emilio Pagan. The pipeline produced Griffin Jax as a reliever and Ober finally broke through as a quality starter, but that was about it. Louie Varland was a passable fifth starter/long reliever and likes of Sands and Funderburk cleaned up some low leverage innings.
DJL44: Part of the problem is they are incredibly reliant on the MLB draft to fill the pitching pipeline. They are getting nothing from their international scouting.
A+ comment, I rarely ever see anyone talk about this but we’re three years in the future and we still have absolutely nothing developed from minors to majors from our international prospects. I will be covering this in a later part of my series.
September 2022: Nick Nelson’s Will Louie Varland Be Falvey's First Pitching Development Success Story?
Varland's got everything you could want: outstanding performance at every level, legitimate high-octane stuff, and -- perhaps most critically, where the Twins are concerned -- a seemingly strong bill of health and durability. Of course, those things were also true of Ober and Winder, and any number of other promising ascendant arms in this organization ... until they weren't. Petty is gone. Matt Canterino's out of the picture until 2024. Winder's health is an ongoing question mark. Jordan Balazovic has seen his stock plunge amidst a nightmare season.
For even as pessimistic as I can be on the subject, I wouldn’t claim that there hadn’t been a single pitching development success story. Seth agrees with that sentiment:
SethStohs: Ryah, Duran... I would say Jax has absolutely been a success. Thielbar was older and had been around, but they got the best out of him. And, what's exciting is the pipeline. Obviously not all will make it, but the more that develop well, the more options down the line. David Festa was a Day 3 guy in 2021 and he's been dominant at two levels (this year's Varland). Jaylen Nowlin, their 19th round pick last year, has been very good.
KirbyDome89: The "pipeline," is a meme at this point. Every organization has a Festa or Nowlin; guys in low minors who maybe if things break right find themselves in a major league rotation. That can't be where the goalposts are shifting.
Dman: The OP is right I went into the year defending the FO for a pitching pipeline that had Balazovich, Sands, Henriquez, Winder, Duran, Enlow on the horizon, Varland, SWR, with some young guys coming up in Povich, Hajjar and Petty with outside chances in SGL, Headrick, Mooney and Festa. Almost all of it has cratered or been traded away. It almost feels like they are back to square one.
I don’t remember this one! The article name certainly fits into my analysis.
September 2022: Cody Christie’s “Minnesota's Pitching Pipeline Plan Failed in 2022”
Derek Falvey was brought to Minnesota because of his experience with the Cleveland organization. During his Cleveland tenure, one of his calling cards was cultivating young pitching, which has been a staple of the Guardians organization. Minnesota was going to start the 2022 campaign with Ryan and Ober in the rotation, but there were expectations that other young pitchers would join their ranks. Unfortunately, that hasn't been the case, and Minnesota's pitching pipeline may have taken a step back this season… Many will blame injuries for the Twins' failures during the 2022 season. However, the lack of contributions from the pitching pipeline is also concerning. Not every pitching prospect can be successful throughout their professional careers, and there is hope that some of these arms will get healthy in the offseason. As Minnesota's focus turns to 2023, the front office might not be able to rely as heavily on the pitching pipeline when building next year's roster.
Ted Schwerzler: They’re hoping to have the likes of Simeon Woods Richardson, Jordan Balazovic, Ronny Henriquez, Blayne Enlow, and Cole Sands give them real starter innings. Everyone mentioned there is close ...
USAFChief: And there we have it, folks...the first use of the vaunted "pitching pipeline" meme for 2023!
September 2022 marks the transition of “pitching pipeline” transitioning from talking point to meme. And the frustration continued to boil over:
December 2022: Brock Beauchamp’s “That’s it. I’m pretty much done with this front office.”
I’m tired of trading for injured pitchers. I’m tired of the lack of pitching development. I simply don’t see many reasons to keep them around anymore. They’re not exceptional at anything and have significant flaws.
Twins Daily hit a low point when it was announced Carlos Correa had inked a massive deal and wasn’t going to be a Twin, you can imagine the responses in this article echoed Brock’s frustrations. However, as we know in hindsight the 2023 season went on to be a fairly successful one with the team winning 87 games, the division, and finally getting over that playoff bugaboo.
In Part 2, I’ll do some more analysis of the discourse over the 2023 and 2024 seasons. How did the successes of the 2023 season mold the opinions of Falvine and the so-called pitching pipeline? And then how did the big step back in 2024 effect it? Tune in next time to find out.
- Read more...
- 1 comment
- 5,986 views

