Yeah, the scouting failed the strategy with Nishioka, I think. At least it was a serious and bold attempt to fix to a clear need. BS just picked the guy coming off a .400 BABIP-boosted batting title, and then compounded the mistake by dumping Hardy for prospects - perhaps, again, because of a failure in scouting. And in fairness, I'd say the same about the Worley trade. They just happened to trade a fairly established, young MLB talent for a guy with 2 mediocre fastballs and not much else. The concept of trading our CFer for starting pitching was a good one but looks more and more like a failure due to improper talent evaluation or scouting, and not necessarily the GM's lack of aggression. Speaking of Hardy though - it shows how you can trade prospects for MLB talent in "lost" seasons as part of your rebuild. At the time, JJ was only under contract through 2011, one season. That was a Dave Trombley move though, not Duquette.