Seth, really agree with your train of thought here. But you got to go one more level deep: there is another stat that drives BA, and pretty much tells what kind of hitter one is. This is BABIP. Unlike, pitchers' BABIPs (that indicate how lucky a pitcher is, since BABIPs should approximate the league average of around .290), hitters' BABIPs indicate performance. And the higher the batting average in balls in play, the higher the batting average. Hitters with high BABIPs are slap hitters. Ben Revere's and Denard Span's career BABIP is .320 or so. Gary Gaetti's career BABIP (who I think might be a good comparable for Dozier's power ceiling) is .270. I spent some time graphing Dozier's BABIP and IsoP thought out the years. Here: So it looks like when Dozier used to hit for a high average with a High BABIP, he hit like Span and Revere. And as his IsoP increased, his BABIP decreased to the point that his BA was suppressed. Gaetti had a career .179 IsoP, a career .270 BABIP and a career .255 Batting Average. I think that this is where Dozier might be heading or towards the career numbers of his current hitting coach, .188 IsoP, .259 BABIP, .245 BA, if you want another example