I don't understand the hate here. Plouffe botched a few plays, but he's also made some truly great ones. he didn't have an error through 10 games and botched a few when it was terrible weather. Let him get a few more attempts and his defensive metrics will return to normal. He is an average glove. He has 218 games at 3b in his professional career. I do think he has the skills to keep improving. Nobody is saying he will be as steady as Koskie, but league average shouldn't be that difficult. In 2012 his fielding % was .935, league average was .952. So, 1.7% difference. I have a hard time believing that after adjusting to a new position and being able to spend his time working there wont produce better results, even if they are marginal (which is all they need to be). His range factors are pretty close to league average too. So saying he is terrible, is just wrong. I get it. Plouffe is rarely flashy or smooth. He hasn't come through in some high leverage situations. I find it funny that someone can bash him when he is currently in the top 10 in the league for OPS, is coming off a 20+ HR season, is still only 26 and is getting comfortable at a new position. Even if he never gets better on D and is simply below average, his bat more than makes up for it. I'd rather have a good bat with below average defense than mediocre bat and mediocre glove.