Why would Rosario be a lock while Hicks is bound to struggle in your opinion? Hicks: .276/.327/.423 WRC+ 105 Rosario: .279/.301/.455 WRC+ 104 Now, from these stats they have been fairly similiar with Rosario showing more slugging and Hicks are higher OBP. What these stats don't show you is Rosario's BB% of 3.2% and K% of 23.6%, meanwhile Hicks BB% is 6.9 and K% is 15.8%. While Hick's BB% is down considerably from last year, his K% is down almost 10%. Eddie needs to figure out how to cut down on that K% if he is virtually never going to walk. While their averages are the same, Rosario's is fueled by a .348 BABIP, which while not as high as Dan San's .405 last year, it is probably unsustainable. Even with Hick's struggle against right handed batters, Rosario struggles against lefties are near identical. Hicks vs RHP: .243/.293/.355 .639 OPS wRC+ 76 Rosario vs LHP: .241/.273/.367 .641 OPS wRC+ 73 If anything they would make a pretty insane platoon for each other.