Oh, I've said it before, and it's almost a self-parody by now. But i do think they put in some time and effort, not on primary scouting themselves, but synthesizing scouting reports from somewhere. They do not state exactly how they create their scouting ratings (and I've asked). I find that their ratings track pretty well, when I compare them for instance to individual articles about players or whatever. The big thing is it's comprehensive, for every player in every major league organization, plus a lot of upcoming prospects for the June draft - so I can look up any player on a moment's notice and get a sense of their skill set. Without further coyness: Out Of The Park Baseball I find OOTP worth the $35 or so for each year's new version, just for the scouting insights alone. (I might also have devoted an hour, or two, or more, to playing the game during the past year. ) Scoffers, scoff as ye will - I deserve it and I own up to it.