The late-inning bullpen should be expected to extract a win from a 2-run lead in the ninth. 40% But scoring 3 runs in 9 innings is not winning baseball. Yes, Kyle Gibson is a pretty good pitcher. But if this team flatters itself to think it's playoff-bound, they will face pretty good pitchers each and every game in Octoberball. This loss is in great part attributable to the bats. 30% The starter consumed 101 pitches and covered only 16 outs. That is not winning baseball either. The game was handed to the bullpen in the 6th inning, and for a few innings they actually did their job, but you can't expect perfection over and over, so the starters have to succeed for longer. 20% The damage was done before Rocco had to choose a 10th inning arm, but he did choose strangely. 10% This loss was a team effort, and that's how I'd allocate blame.