But that's because it's not a choice between hanging KC out to dry in the 8th, versus putting in the reliever. IMO both those options can be criticized without it being second guessing. That's because it's almost standard practice to do what has already been suggested: Get Burton and Duensing up and warming up while the Twins are batting (if Duensing is not available that day, pick your best option for getting lefties out, maybe that's Burton anyway); Send Correia out there and tell him "go get 'em"; At the first baserunner, send in the correct-handed reliever; go from there. This is not rocket surgery - managers do it all the time. And it gives you the chance at the better of both worlds: if your mediocre starter is having one of the games of his life, he has a chance to finish his complete game shutout if he gives up no hits in the 8th (and maybe his team scores a few in the 9th to give him a better cushion for when he goes out for the bottom of that inning), and if his run of luck is up, it costs you only a baserunner (hopefully not a home run). I'm not saying I thought this through, as I watched the game unfold. But it's what Gardy is paid to have figured out ahead of time. And his explanations afterward continue to sound to me like a rationalization for something else going on under the surface.