RB, it's even more than you say: had the Twins hung onto him, arbitration would likely have given him a series of escalating contracts, whereas after being cut he had very little salary leverage. And yet these other teams cut a nearly no-cost commodity. If the Twins were dumb, these two teams were even dumber. (A movie parody suggests itself here.) The only counter-argument I can see is that these decisions to cut him weren't by teams with a track record of great talent evaluation. Had the Cardinals or Giants cut him, then it would be fair to say 'who knew?'. OTOH, the counter-counter argument is that neither of the Cardinals or Giants have chosen to take a flyer on the enigma called Kevin Slowey, so maybe that says something as well. /edit: Spycake correctly pointed out that the next two teams were on the same hook for salary as the Twins would have been. So if Slowey turns out to be the next Cy Young winner, the Rox and Tribe will have been exactly as dumb as the Twins, not dumber. Saying that here, rather than add to the thread length.