That must be b-r.com WAR. On Fangraphs, the total tilts to Cuddy, which I think is appropriate given near equal OPS+ and Willingham's nearly non-existent defense. Cuddy is no defensive whiz either, but at least he would have been willing to "take his talents" to RF, where the Twins had the hole in 2012. Given that the Twins are nowhere near bumping into any financial constraints, I'd rather have Cuddyer even at higher money; part of my delight in signing Willingham was the mistaken assumption the difference would be applied to getting a better starting pitcher that off-season.