Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

tony&rodney

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    10,779
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    94

 Content Type 

Profiles

Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by tony&rodney

  1. I'm still waiting and not sold at all on the direction, not yet at least and I'm not referring to Ober and Larnach.
  2. This seems about right. The Twins could always reach out to a few clubs and make an offer or two that is a temptation. I have no real ideas here. Maybe Colorado listens to a thought of Lewis, Matthews, and Quick for T. J. Rumfield. That might be too much or not enough or the Rockies may not even consider moving their first baseman. Rumfield might not be worth it either. That is just a thought. I haven't looked closely at Rumfield. An easy move would be to talk/bribe either Ty France or Brandon Lowe into signing with the Twins. They may both want three year contracts. I like these guys because they are both professional bats who work pitchers even when they are in slumps. My go to suggestion has been to add speed and defense to the bottom of the roster if it isn't available for a regular position. I like Ryan Kreidler. Unless the Twins pull off some major trade that lands a shortstop like Elly De La Cruz, I think the Twins need Kreidler. His steady play is worth an out or two each game above what someone like Tristan Gray or Brooks Lee provides. Maybe Ben Ross grows into that role. The player I have proposed as an acquisition is Jordan Lawlar. He is a buy low player and it isn't sure if Arizona will listen, but they have needs. Tempt them. Agree with staying aggressive.
  3. The comments here mirror what has been written about Lewis since he arrived in one way in that people have strong opinions on what Lewis is like and his worth. Previously, Lewis was a darling who had the best positive attitude and was certain to be a superstar. Hordes of comments were made about signing him to a long term lucrative contract. My how far Lewis has fallen in the eyes of some fans. He is still in a group of people, behind Buxton and Keaschall, in terms of speed. His defense is still reasonable and he is improving in that skill area. Lewis can be the other half of Kody Clemens too. The salary is not out of line. My main beef with Lewis is his low on base percentage. I'm fine with the Twins trading Lewis and will not think it a mistake if he is not tendered a contract. I would keep him until there is a better alternative already in place. I can see why folks are opposed to a long term contract. The primary offer proposed by Seth is low by baseball standards and because Lewis initially banked a substantial signing bonus, it is hard to know if he would find that palatable. I'm year to year on Royce. He can be replaced via free agent, trade, or advancing prospects.
  4. Below this paragraph is what I wrote on a board related to Lewis recently. I too have changed my mind. Call it a crappy hunch, but I could see Lewis being somewhat humbled by his 2026 campaign and adopting some different approaches. Lewis is on a minimal contract. He wasn't really good at third base but he was ok. He managed to pick up first base better than expected and was particularly good at scooping poor throws even as he struggled with the nuances of where to line up on relays or occasionally wandering too far off the bag on grounders to the second baseman. At the dish, Lewis has worn out his welcome with many because of his addiction to the low outside pitches, which he obstinately attempts to pull. The other side of the coin is that Lewis is not someone with high K rates, he can run a little bit, and the ball still comes off his bat in a sweet fashion. In various iterations of a roster, often I have dumped Lewis from the team. That has changed. I'm now more inclined to hold him unless he returns real value. The only way Lewis returns value is if he is packaged with another player like Ryan. I don't see a good trade for Ryan so this leaves Royce at 1B if the Twins can bring in Brandon Lowe or 2B if the Twins choose to sign Ty France. Lewis will be a better defender than Clemens after he gets the repetitions he needs to learn the position because he is more athletic. While I never previously bought into the hype for Royce Lewis because I saw only an undisciplined player, I now see a rehabbing guy who may come into 2027 with his legs back to what can be his 100% health going forward. I also think he will finally adopt the approaches his coaches have brought to him about punishing those middle and middle high outside pitches to right field while laying off the outside worm borers. It could happen but I could be stone cold wrong too.
  5. Oh, I am on agreement with that and if you have seen my occasional comments I have mentioned it. We all know that the CBA requires the two sides to come to an agreement. First the owners must agree amongst themselves about revenue sharing and then they can take step one. What is revenue and what percentage is set aside for the players.
  6. You might have this reversed. If the players can get 60% of "all" revenues, which would be independently reviewed in audits, the players would then likely agree to a cap and floor. As far as common sense ... you know how that goes.
  7. For the umpteenth time, Lawlar is not out for the year. "Diamondbacks outfielder Jordan Lawlar recently had Tommy John brace surgery to repair a ligament in his right (throwing) elbow, but he is expected to be fully recovered for the start of next season." from mlb.com Arizona page
  8. Yes, Morejon for 4 or 5 years would be risky. Gray for 2 years is great but not crazy. Sign Morejon too.
  9. The owners and Manfred keep wanting a system of total control. This has been ongoing since 1976. It's not news. Hockey has 32 teams. Hockey. Open San Jose, LA, NYC, and Charlotte for teams. Billionaires will step forward.
  10. That would be a real get for the Twins. I'm thinking Larnach has value in combination with another player, be it Martin, Wallner, Kremer, Ober, Lewis, or a prospect like Tait. My past take was Arizona would find Larnach useful along with Ober and utility player Lawlar could work for the Twins. Most people have disagreed. I'm all ears on potential trades.
  11. Or maybe, despite all of us ancient dying corpses still being rabid fans, baseball has just fallen behind Soccer, basketball, football, hockey, and whatever else is next up. The people who decided the recent election were 18-50 and that is the crowd that will decide where baseball goes too. There are always billionaires who want to be a part of some exclusive club. There is a certain crowd that has to be seen. MLB can expand whenever it wants. There will a number of people willing to pay a couple of their extra billions to join the club and they will coerce a city into building a stadium too. Why does anyone join Mar A Lago? You couldn't pay Warren Buffett $10M a day to join. He makes money, is happy to pay taxes, and enjoys life at his own speed in Omaha. The CBA will be solved once the owners come to some agreements amongst themselves. It really isn't complicated at all.
  12. Don't disagree. What is the plan though? Is it to compete for a year? No problem with that, but what then?
  13. Someone must do some market analysis, right? Maybe not. While I'm sure even Audra had her detractors, This seems like an odd decision. Audra was always upbeat, a good sport as far as taking a few jokes, and maintained a solid approach to her job from my perspective. We have no idea how a club budgets their different departments, unless someone is inside the books, but it seems like quite a few jobs that don't add up to much have been cut in recent seasons. Maybe savings on paper clips is important.
  14. Is there any similarity between the moves the last two days to signing Correa and/or Donaldson? One thing that is not clear to me is the direction of the Twins. What is the plan?
  15. I can wait before giving a verdict. As far as the CBA, the owners should start by ridding themselves of Manfred. After that they can get together and decide amongst themselves how to distribute revenue. When that conversation has occurred the PA can be brought in to negotiate a settlement.
  16. I don't disagree but it is also true that any individual can use whatever stats they want to support their position or to counter another argument. We hear all the time that wins, BA, runs scored, rbi's, etc. are meaningless. The production of analytics has been around forever or certainly in my lifetime (8th decade), but the internet has created a way for many people to make money. That's fine. It is why this site exists. Just remember that money drives decisions and folks who construct really interesting crap, whether it is WAR or whatever, are hoping to cash in. The wider anything is shared the more people see it as legitimate.
  17. Dustin May has not really been worth a contract since 2020. I have been intrigued by May, myself, given his size and pitches. Those are independent though from what transpires after he releases the ball. Unless we are judging pitchers strictly on stuff, Ober has been and continues to be a better MLB pitcher than Dustin May. The Twins just signed Sonny Gray, so evaluations cannot be purely on stuff and size. No I'm not comparing Ober to Gray, I was comparing the results year after year for Ober and May.
  18. We are all guessing like crazy. The one point that seems to get regurgitated is that the Twins have overstepped their financial boundary. As such a slew of comments and this article point to reductions possible by dropping some combination of players. The date for offering arbitration approaches quickly, which will provide some knowns. Are the salaries of the players mentioned beyond the worth of the players? Looking over the list, one can easily justify keeping all of the arbitration eligible players. Ryan, Bradley, and Kremer are easy calls. Ober gets forwarded plenty of times for a release but he has never produced less than 1 WAR; he earns his keep. Nance and Sands are easy keepers if they are healthy due to their minimum salaries. Clemens is a lock to be offered a contract. That leaves us with two controversial guys in Larnach and Lewis. It is hard to believe that neither has any value for a potential transaction, yet both are borderline calls due to their spotty production. The pst failures to find trading partners for players is a thing in these decisions. One would think that Arizona or San Diego, to name two clubs, would have an interest in a few of the listed players. Where the payroll sits is a pointless effort as shown by the past two days. I would tender all of the players but work on transactions for several. The returns only need to add some balance to the organization, it does not have to be for starting players.
  19. Many of us have made attempts to come up with realistic trades using Joe Ryan, which return a significant bat. With the exception of Ryan for Devers, there simply haven't been any ideas. Devers is a very poor first baseman but could DH. He has 7/$210M+ remaining on his contract. I'm going to suggest that there is zero chance of such a trade. So .... who else? Please forward a guess or two. In the column under "Opinions that vary greatly from person to person; i.e to each their own", my opinion is that Joe Ryan is the Twins best starting pitcher. I'm open to trading Ryan and am aware that the return will not be as special as it might have been in July 2025, but I'm also not in favor of dumping him for virtually nothing.
  20. Assuming full health is a tricky proposition but if so .... 1. Joe Ryan 2. Pablo Lopez 3. Sonny Gray 4. Taj Bradley 5. Connor Prielipp
  21. I agree but a transaction that involves Caratini needs to be completed at the same time. I must admit to having no knowledge of the worth of Ober or Kremer, Would San Diego trade Freddy Fermin for Kremer and Caratini plus $4M? That gives the Twins a really good defensive catcher, moves Caratini, and saves around $8M+. Davis might be available for Martin and Sands. I think the Twins keep Caratini though.
  22. Luis Arraez battling a pitcher is a fun plate appearance to watch. However, Arraez does not get enough XBH, he doesn't drive in enough runs, he doesn't score enough runs, he is pretty slow, and he has not previously been decent in the field. I like Arraez but the Twins need a BIG bat. The choices on the free agent market are limited to Brandon Lowe and Ty France. I'm good with either guy. I'm not sure who the Twins can acquire via trade.
×
×
  • Create New...