tony&rodney
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
10,778 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
94
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by tony&rodney
-
Can The Twins Trust Their Three Rookies In 2027?
tony&rodney replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
None of Wallner, Miranda, Julien, or Kirilloff owned a glove or were very capable running. We can add Larnach to that list. We can have more confidence in this group athletically. It is possible that not all of the rookies will be regulars when the dust settles. However, as noted above the Twins have no choice but to play these guys. I would add Marek Houston asap. It seems like the best idea to let them play. I would suggest that the Twins need to add a free agent like Brandon Lowe. The rookies cannot be the only plan.- 56 replies
-
- kaelen culpepper
- walker jenkins
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
It is really difficult to read what other teams want. Does Arizona still want starting pitching? All teams do, but is Ober or Kremer an acceptable player for them. I would suggest that teams need 4th/5th SP. Does Arizona still want a LH bat? Larnach has very limited value. What about Alan Roden? As such, there may be a world where Arizona is wiling to trade Lawlar for a Roden and Ober or Kremer package. Maybe Zebby Matthews for Lawlar. I have heard too many insults that Lawlar is too highly valued. He wasn't used much. Lawlar is not that valuable given his struggles and propensity to wind up on the IL, but I target him as a talented reserve outfielder who could play on the dirt in an emergency and he can run. The specifics here are not that important. The identification of potential roster help is though and the Twins have been over balanced and sat on their assets too often. I would be in conversations with other teams on all sorts of players. It only takes 5-10 minutes. Trades should be mutually beneficial. St. Louis is flush with young catchers. So, what do they want? Even outlandish impossible ideas can be discussed for 5 minutes. The Reds are frustrated because Elly De La Cruz will not sign long term. Is there any possibility of a deal there? I think it is close to 1%, but I would ask. While I know Ryan has seen a large drop in his value, there are bound to be numerous clubs still interested in him. I think the Twins should hold Ryan until July but listen on ideas or offers. The Dodgers, Padres, and others could offer decent returns. Zoll needs to be active in November. The last thing I want to read or hear is that the Twins had some good conversations that laid a foundation for further contact after the CBA is settled.
- 87 replies
-
- ty france
- ryan jeffers
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I understand the wish for a draft choice. I'm afraid that there is a chance that Ryan Jeffers accepts the QO. I'm ready for the Twins pitchers to have a real catcher to throw to and I really don't care about the bat. This is my opinion and I recognize the opposite side, but I disagree as do Cleveland and many other teams. FWIW, I don't believe that Milwaukee would use Ryan Jeffers as a catcher.
-
Dude, I want to read what you wrote but it is not readable unless I want to take 5 minutes to put in Capital letters, punctuation, and fix the word order, grammar, etc. I'm not rejecting whatever you want to say. I am rejecting the unreadable text. I am confident you can use sentences to convey your thoughts, which others will then read.
-
When next season begins, I will still be a baseball fan and a Twins fan. Every year I hope the team improves. Some times those suggested improvements require increased expenditures and at other times I hope for savvy trades. I sat 5 feet from Dusty Baker in the 2023 playoffs and knew the Twins needed change. The Twins have sat on their hands quite a bit. The frenzy of action at the 2025 trade deadline was not followed up, which left me with a frown. Shelton let the players show their skills and then managed to convince management and the players to shift positions. This was a positive move. In all cases, I'm still a fan. I'm hoping and pushing. Where we (and actually almost everyone else here on TD but not everyone) disagree is on Ryan Jeffers. I think in the other cases we mol agree. Reality is not something to ignore though. Gleeman has been screaming for years for a much larger roster expenditure. I don't see that as something we have any control over and have consistently pushed forward multiple plans for rosters. One possible and one likely. The front office has options every year. We see teams like TB, CLE, MIl, and more make their own futures whereas the Twins mostly sit. The money is less important than the moves as we clearly saw when Falvey spent more money than any of his ALC opponents during his tenure. So spend more. Absolutely, but spend smart.
-
The heat is on for this Twins front office. They get November to perform. By December 1, we should have a solid indication of the direction of the franchise. Rolling it back with all of the usual positive comments that highlight how improved Johnny or Judy will be next season due to their offseason work without seeing change with the roster would be a downer.
- 6 replies
-
- ryan jeffers
- joe ryan
- (and 7 more)
-
Twins Decline Options on Joe Ryan and Josh Bell
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
That is an interesting thought. It would not be crossing a picket line because the players are not going on strike. The owners are locking out players. As such it seems unlikely the owners would make decisions that go against their position. I'm wondering how many people believe there will be a lockout that extends into May. Poll? -
I agree with that. Can I remind you that I pushed for the Twins to trade several players last offseason, especially Joe Ryan and Bailey Ober. Ryan is my favorite Twins pitcher to watch but he had value last November. Now? Still some value, but perhaps that is greater for the Twins now. We shall see. I push back on the idea that the Twins currently on the 40 roster have little to no value. There are still opportunities. I'm uncertain where the demand is (from what teams) but believe there is interest and it is up to Zoll and the front office to manage transactions that improve the roster.
- 87 replies
-
- ty france
- ryan jeffers
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
OH, I'm ok with the Pohlads/Twins spending a ton of money. No problem. It's not my money and it would fine with me to see the Twins roll with a $175M+ roster in 2027. Perhaps I'm exceptionally naive but I don't see it, although I would support it. Roster choices are largely opportunity costs for our Twins. But sure, Sign Jeffers and also sign Morejon, Bednar, Lowe, and Bauers too.
-
Agree Jeffers should have been traded. Just a note to say that the something could be a #75 pick, not a #35 pick. That value is not worth a $23M gamble. I'm not convinced the QO should be made. There is a chance Jeffers accepts the large one year deal. The Twins made a mistake by not trading him and it would be another mistake to roster two catchers for $30M+, unless the roster budget is $160M+. So it is related but I certainly could have extended and explained the response more fully. Regrets on that.
-
Can we know what value players have for other teams much less to their own team? For just a few examples - how does one compare Ober, Roden, Larnach who seemingly have low value to Lawlar who would seem to be in the same boat? Where does a promising but unheralded rookie like Bernal fit as compared to Matthews? Elly DLC is a superstar with only 3 years left. Is he sky high? Valuations are difficult to determine.
- 87 replies
-
- ty france
- ryan jeffers
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
3 Bold Predictions for Minnesota Twins’ Offseason
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The Cubs have some serious fans. They have tried to trade Matt Shaw all year with no luck and would take Tristan Gray if they could slide it by the Ricketts.- 53 replies
-
- royce lewis
- ownership
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Does the word "available" refer strictly to free agents. Does the word "catcher" refer to anyone who has caught? There is plenty to like about Ryan Jeffers from an outsiders point of view. Viewed from the vantage point of a pitcher, Jeffers is a DH. Is he a better DH than Josh Bell? Maybe a different thought is worth thinking about. Why does Cleveland choose to use catchers like Patrick Bailey or Austin Hedges? This entire discussion comes down down to what an individual wants from their catcher. Clearly, the overwhelming majority of folks on Twins Daily want a guy who has a bat. Just know that there is a world that a few people see a catcher's main role as a receiver of pitches. Think William Contreras. Think Patrick Bailey. Think Henry Davis. If offense is the criteria for catcher, Ryan Jeffers is your guy. The results follow. In fairness or transparency I must admit a negative attitude about throwing to a catcher like Ryan Jeffers. It had nothing to do with character, intelligence, preparedness, or hitting. It's the work behind the plate. Count me as a person stunned by a comment by someone that Jeffers was as good as William Contreras except for throwing. Apparently analytics are worse than I ever imagined if that can be shown. Eyes don't always lie.
-
Given the outside view, do you still think the Twins should give Jeffers a qualifying offer? If so, why? If not, why not? A connected issue is the payroll. Where do you see the payroll? If it is a penny less than $150M, I cannot see how the team gets to a .500 record if they have $30M+ spent on catchers.
-
What I am reading in the comments is that Jeffers must be signed or given a QO (he would take it) or the Twins are out of it. This position is in stark contrast to Cleveland rostering Patrick Bailey and Austin Hedges or the Los Angeles Dollars turning to Ben Rortvedt when Will Smith went down. Jeffers is more of a DH than a catcher but a team can put him behind the plate similar to Garver when he was a Twin. Is Jeffers a better DH than Josh Bell? There are many things to think about here. The Twins made definite moves to improve their defense last year. Catcher is the most important position of the eight guys if we separate out the pitcher. Will the Twins punt defense at that most important defensive position that has a direct affect on the pitching staff? It is a topic to at least consider. I have no idea which way the Twins will go. As a Twins fan I cheer either way and just hope for the best. It is very clear where the vast majority side on this issue. I know where I stand. I had dozens of occasions to use the better hitter as my catcher but filled in the card with the stronger defender, using the hitter when possible to PH or DH. Of course, these guys were not getting paid so that changes the calculus. It would be a surprise to me if the Twins decided to pull back on their ideas to improve their club defensively. As always, we shall see what happens in time.
-
Put yourself in Ryan Jeffers' shoes. He can sign for 3/$40M (best case) or QO of $23M (guaranteed) with a club he already knows and plan on an injury free successful season in 2027 after which he goes back on the market under a new CBA. Worst case (extremely unlikely) Jeffes gets 2/$20M. QO plus worst case still beats what he can expect on the market. We shall see soon enough. This is all just cold morning meaningless speculation on our parts and nobody should get upset about the comments in any direction. Put yourself in Zoll's shoes or whomever makes the call. You are going to sign a catcher who fits best at DH for $23M when you already have another guy (Caratini) on the books for $10M (includes buyout)? That would mean more than $80M for Lopez, Buxton, Correa, and catchers. At that point I need to spend around an additional $80M+ to fill out a fair roster. Tom? Can you guarantee that payroll? The beauty of it all is that we will find out. It is interesting, for me, to read contrasting opinions on this. What I want to read is responses that defend a signing/QO, a minimal nod towards the importance of defense for the catching position or a statement suggesting that defense is vastly overrated. It doesn't add anything to just put thumb down without an explanation of rationale.
-
A House Full of Twins Legends
tony&rodney commented on IndianaTwin's blog entry in Un/Necessary Sports Drivel
Eight knee surgeries for Tony Oliva in an era when surgery was to fillet a person before fixing "things". Love the lists and commentary for both lists. Supernovas - Lyman Bostock? What a player, what a person (jibber jabber), what a tragedy. I will never forget that 1977 season. -
Do the Twins Have a Pitching Development Problem?
tony&rodney replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Minor League Talk
Eventually the Twins will need to dip into the pool of free agent pitchers to bolster their starting staff. Obviously the bullpen needs help for next year. The alternative is to acquire pitching via trades and push them forward. It is probably fair to say that all teams are searching for more pitchers. Development is an ongoing process.- 23 replies
-
- connor prielipp
- taj bradley
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:
-
This is a fair comment. It really is something to think of a team having Duran, Jax, and Varland together. The Twins are hoping, against some steep odds that Mick Abel and Kendry Rojas can step forward in a large way and that Taj Bradley maintains or improves upon his 2026 season. It could happen and is roughly $15M less expensive. Your note does jar the reality of forecasting something beyond 81 wins for 2027. We (Twins fans) are depending/hoping for sustained positives from unknowns such as Jenkins, Rodriguez, Culpepper, Houston, Roden, Rojas, Abel, and Prielipp along with the expectation that the club gets solid gains from Lee, Clemens, and Lewis. That is not to mention the wishes for Buxton, Lopez, Ryan, etc. It is quite a wish list and I'm wishing too. Hopefully Zoll and his friends all show up to work early Monday morning for the most important month of work in their careers. Tune in.

