Hunter's case is interesting because of how much it relies on defense, career longevity, and intangibles/personality. His defense is not competitive with some of the all time best glove-only savants elected by the veterans committee, but it doesn't need to be, since he was a very good hitter. It only needs to be among the best of his era. Nine Gold Gloves is an impressive accomplishment that can't be explained away entirely by reputation, and few would argue that Hunter was an excellent center fielder. However, the numbers tell a different story. The standard caveats about defensive metrics apply, but the bottom line is that they don't appear to support the notion of Hunter as a HOF candidate. Older stats like RF/9 confirm Hunter as a standout in CF early in his career, placing him first in the AL in 2000 and 2001. But RF9 pegs him as good but not great for the rest of his CF days, consistently placing him 5th or so in the AL. Total Zone is even more discouraging, grading his CF range as neutral or negative in all but his brilliant 2001 and anomalous 2011 seasons, and totaling a dismal -32 for his career. That leaves longevity and personality/intangibles. Hunter has had a long career and has managed to age gracefully while also finding his way into the postseason on occasion. But he hasn't been a cornerstone of a championship team, and counting stats enhanced by longevity don't carry the same weight with younger, more sabre-oriented HOF voters that they do with the old timers. That leaves personality. As a sort of silly effort to "quantify" personality, here's a half- (or perhaps even quarter-) arsed comparable for Hunter (JAWS and WAR career totals vs. /average HOF career totals at their primary position). Hunter: Gray Ink - 29 HoF Monitor - 58 HoF Standards - 33 WAR- 50.8 /70.4 JAWS- 41.0/57.2 "Player B" Gray Ink - 67 HoF Monitor - 68 HoF Standards - 33 WAR - 44.6/69.3 JAWS - 41.5/56.9 All in all, Player B's HoF scores represent an aggregate very similar to Hunter's. Player B did not win multiple GG's like Hunter but was widely regarded as an excellent up-the-middle defender in his prime. He was a starter for a championship team, but his career ended several seasons short of what Hunter has amassed so far. What does all this tell us about the role of personality in the HoF chances of a player with borderline numbers? It depends almost entirely on how you feel about electing Chuck Knoblauch to the Hall of Fame.