The thing about luck is that there is no inevitable "counter-luck" to balance the season. The Twins have been moderately lucky, yes, but their BaseRuns record is 28-29 so it's not an extreme shift in either direction (and BaseRuns is a better metric than pythag, as it tries to measure a lot more than just pure run output). The Twins could play .500 ball the rest of the season (which is close to their BaseRuns output thus far) and challenge for the division and wild card deep into the season. One six week long hot streak from Brian Dozier and they can be quite a bit better than that, either winning the division or a wild card appearance. The Twins are a flawed team, yes. That's why I wouldn't break open the farm for an expensive rental. But, on the other hand, I'm not going to give up on a team with a legit shot at the postseason just because they're imperfect. Lots of teams are imperfect and go deep into the postseason. And none of this brings up the long-term PR hit you'd see from trading Santana and/or Dozier (though I'm more open to trading Dozier if it helps the 2017 squad). Baseball attendance lags by nearly a season. The Twins would be leaving literally millions of dollars on the table for 2018 by punting on the season and closing the year with a 78 win season versus an 85 win season and postseason contention.