Teams did agree to to the international signing rules, BIRD, and no rules are being broken. This has been pointed out now many times over. Teams have have decided to take the financial hit and sacrifice their ability to sign players the following year and it appears more will do so again next year. Any team can do this, including the Twins. Unless the rules get changed, this is perfectly legal, ethical and every team has the ability to do it. You are the one who keeps bringing up the payroll, I simply used it as another example of what many would consider questionable ethics. So enough of trying to misdirect the discussion. AGAIN I'm not arguing that the Twins need to stick to the statement that they'd spend 52% of revenue. AGAIN I am arguing against your claim that breaking a non-existent rule that you (and many of us) wish were in place is unethical. It isn't.