I agree that Close is not completely without blame in the situation, but it's important to note the timeline of events in this case. The Astros didn't offer the $5M in a formal offer until hours before the signing deadline. The only formal offer they had made previously was the 40% of the slot value to ensure they got a draft pick. At the same time they restarted negotiations with a 21st round HS pick, Mac Marshall. So, if your Aiken and Close, and you hear that the Astros want to sign Marshall for $1.5M, and they make an informal offer that reduces your bonus by the same amount, and they tell you that it is due to a medical concern that may or may not be an actual issue, wouldn't you be a little angry about the situation too? As for the original question, I believe that both picks are protected this year. The only way that the Astros could lose those picks is if the league decides that the Astros broke the rules, or that they had made an official offer to Nix. If they decide a formal offer is made and Nix signs it, the Astros would be over the cap, I thought that I read both first round picks would forfeited, but I could have misread that,