Sure he could close, and he'd probably dominate. But Trevor May is a big, strong, young, talented pitcher that could develop into an excellent starter. Before you make him a reliever, you better exhaust all your other options, which is what the Twins did before they stuck May in the pen this season. Trevor May has been an extremely good soldier by going to the bull pen when the team needed a reliever. He went there and proceeded to become the most reliable arm in the pen. He should be rewarded next spring with a legitimate shot to get back into the starting rotation. Besides, next spring the closer might be grabbed by Nick Burdi, J.T. Chargois or one of the other flame throwers.